Cineman
Second Unit
- Joined
- May 30, 2011
- Messages
- 485
- Real Name
- David B.
I think the reason Hitchock shows us the faces of the attendees at the Embassy registering discomfort is because DD is signing the song so inappropriately loud. On purpose. She isn't interested in entertaining the Embassy audience with that song, familiar to them or not, so much as "yelling" it to signal to her son, who she and Stewart know is somewhere in that building, that his mom and dad are there to rescue him.MARNIE, is my least favorite Blu-ray, ever. It looks horrible to me. As for DD singing in THE MAN WHO KNEW TOO MUCH, I simply don't get the issue with it being done in the hotel room. The kid is singing it, and mom joins in. Something they often do together. It being sung at the Embassy is what's out of place. Hitchcock even conveys this with the looks of awkwardness on the faces of many of the people in attendance. It's, obviously, not a song that Jo Conway sang on stage, or on records, so their reactions is "what's this?" It's her desperate attempt at communicating her presence to her son. He hears a song he knows, then listens more intently and realizes it's his mother singing it. Everything about its existence in the film makes perfect sense, plot-wise. My guess is that if the song did not become a number 1 hit, and forever associated with Doris Day, nobody would have the slightest issue with it, as I'm sure no one did, when the film was originally in theaters.
Last edited: