Anyways, I'm rambling. As for people saying they are avid fans of the books and video games, but not like the series, We don't get that. The guy studied this character a lot. We felt like he sounded, walked, and fought the part. My wife has read one or two of the books, I have not, so I can't say for sure there. But we both have played the games extensively. From what we have read, the actor read all the books, played the games and really studied the source material. We felt like he did an amazing job all around.
I am a fan of the game series and was really looking forward to this. However, I didn't make it past episode 2. I found the acting to be bland (at best), the editing and pacing all over the place and the characters unlikeable. Re-watch pretty much ANY episode of Game of Thrones first few seasons after watching this show and see the difference good writing and direction can make.
I don't have a problem with the multiple timelines. I think they didn't want to get too built up in exposition so they get you rolling, then they go back to tell you relevant backstory for each episode. It does get a bit chaotic when you have 3 stories going on, and they aren't taking place simultaneously.
Its quite a bit more than that with Cavill. He's a Witcher fanboy. He had already played the games and read the books. When he heard Netflix optioned the property, he had his agent pestering them weekly. Finally they said "We are not near looking for people yet". He was on a quest to get this role.
Cavill also did everything, no stuntman. No stand-ins. When they were shooting, he would wear his costume and/or armor during off hours, to get more acclimated to it, etc.
Youtube The Witcher and find the interview with Rich Eisen. Its quite entertaining.
There is another link that comes up, that also covers many details (some of which I have mentioned already), but its got some spoilers in it but they tell you to skip forward 30 seconds.
OK. I'm in the midst of a first watch. With zero familiarity with the source material books, or the games.
I just want to know one thing:
Are the books and games so chronologically F-d up?
Why present it like this? It's confusing and frustrating. And certainly not inviting to new audience members.
I had to find an on-line explanation for ANY of this to make sense.
In other words, why not tell an intelligible story?