Don't have time to read it right now, but this is the guy who gave Uncharted 3 a four. What does that mean? I don't know, as I don't have either game. But, just some context.
http://www.honestgamers.com/reviews/9640.html
Now, Nintendo World Report gave Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword a perfect 10 and I know for sure that is 100% above reproach.
I created a character last night with the XBox demo download and am interested in this game but I am not expecting this to be a 10, though I expect it to be fun. IGN gave Uncharted 3 a 10 and Saints Row a 8.5. Other sites are praising Uncharted 3 quite highly, and I loved the second game... one of the best I ever played. Therefore I'm a little suspect of this reviewer who gives Saints Row a 10. Nonetheless, this looks like a fun game and will probably get this instead of GTA V as I have grown tired of that game's premise.
I have all the newest games out right now, so anything you want to know feel free to ask. In regard to the reviews and scores, you have to go by what is best in YOUR view and just use them as a guide. Many games I own were better than their scores I thought and some were a bit worse, it's subjective, except for the really bad ones that you should avoid.
For the ones mentioned, I can say they are all different and worth getting in my opinion. I have enjoyed switching between them and plan to focus mainly on COD 3 and Uncharted 3 for now, then move to Skyrim and Saints.
I'll pick it up when I get most of Skyrim completed, so around march
Right now if you buy this for the PS3 you get a download of Saints Row 2 thrown in. Not a bad deal but there's no trophy support for SR2 that I know of.
Finally got my account fixed last night, had to reset at thq instead of saintsrow.com and not use any special chars. Game is fun if kinda whacked right now, love the UAV!