1. We suffered a brief outage this morning when our host noticed that HTF needed to be moved to a different server due to a hardware failure. That work is now complete. Please post in the feedback area if you have any issues.
    Dismiss Notice

Crimson Rivers Plot Question *SPOILER ALERT*

Discussion in 'Archived Threads 2001-2004' started by John Macri, Nov 7, 2001.

  1. John Macri

    John Macri Stunt Coordinator

    Joined:
    Sep 30, 1997
    Messages:
    91
    Likes Received:
    2
    I watched Crimson Rivers last night and really enjoyed the film although several plot points were confusing. Can someone explain how Judith was swapped at the hospital with the twin sisters? I can't seem to make sense of this situation. How can one girl be exchanged for two and where did the "bad" sister live?
    I might have had a bit too much Chardonnay while watching.... Thanks for the help.
     
  2. Vincent Matis

    Vincent Matis Second Unit

    Joined:
    Jun 1, 1999
    Messages:
    491
    Likes Received:
    0
    My thoughts:
    Judith was swapped with one of the twin sisters (sister A).
    As they grew older, the remaining twin sister -sister B-(probably living with her real mother) became a "danger" for those who swapped the babies: why two girls, born from supposably "different" couples, would resemble each other that much?
    That is why the sister B had an "accident", her body could not be identified, the school photos were stolen,...).
    Vincent
    ------------------

    AFI Top 100 Films Home Theater Forum Challenge

    AFI Movies Left To Watch: 34 33 32 31 30: Sound Of Music (3.5 out of 4)
     
  3. John Macri

    John Macri Stunt Coordinator

    Joined:
    Sep 30, 1997
    Messages:
    91
    Likes Received:
    2
    Vincent:
    Thanks, that answers a couple things but I still confused. So what you're saying is that Judith (University child) is living with the village woman's remaining daughter (sister B - who is later killed in the "accident"). What still confuses me is why Judith is a dead-ringer (no pun intended) for Fanny (sister A)? They look like identical twins! If this is the real explanation they should have cast actresses different in apperance.
     
  4. Vincent Matis

    Vincent Matis Second Unit

    Joined:
    Jun 1, 1999
    Messages:
    491
    Likes Received:
    0
    Sister B was not killed in the accident. The accident was staged by the mother to protect sister B. The mother cut a finger of the sister B and used the body of an already dead girl (remember: the highway employee said that the only thing intact after the accident was a finger the mother was holding in her hand). The police used the finger to identify the remain of the body and closed the case. Judith is now officially "dead"...
    Later, the pictures from sister B's school were stolen to destroy all evidence/hints that she looks exactly like Fanny (sister A)
    Jean Reno (1h33 into the movie):"They only swapped one of the twins, that's why their faces threatened the secrets of the Faculty").
    Hope it clarifies things,
    Vincent
    ------------------

    AFI Top 100 Films Home Theater Forum Challenge

    AFI Movies Left To Watch: 34 33 32 31 30: Sound Of Music (3.5 out of 4)
    [Edited last by Vincent Matis on November 08, 2001 at 04:44 PM]
     
  5. John Macri

    John Macri Stunt Coordinator

    Joined:
    Sep 30, 1997
    Messages:
    91
    Likes Received:
    2
    Vincent:
    Thanks for your patient efforts to explain things for me (and my wife). I really don't expect you to respond to these questions.
    Hmmmm. I'm getting closer, but a few problems still exist. 1) If neither Judith or the twins were killed, what happened to the real Judith (we never see her).
    2) Judith is not the killer - sister "B" is (not a real problem - just a misdirection).
    3) The IMDB lists the following cast:
    Nadia Farès (I) - Fanny Ferreira/Judith Herault
    This means sister A (Fanny) is "now" Judith so who's sister B, has she lived in hiding all this time? And once agian what happened to the original/real Judith?
    The apparent (to me) holes in this plot really detract from what otherwise is a great movie. Even Memento was simpler for me to understand...
     
  6. Vincent Matis

    Vincent Matis Second Unit

    Joined:
    Jun 1, 1999
    Messages:
    491
    Likes Received:
    0
    Before birth:
    Mr. and Mrs. Fereira - girl XYZ
    Mrs. Herault - twins A and B
    1) At birth, girl XYZ is probably killed at birth, she's "replaced" by twin A, she's called Fanny. At the same time, the Doctors told Mrs. Herault that one of the twin is dead...
    2) Mother goes away with twin B (Judith) to live in another French region...
    3) Ten years later, the mother comes back in the village. She realizes that another young girl in the village look exactly like her daughter. She realizes something happened in the nursery. The responsibles @ the nursery and Faculty learn that the mother is back, they try to kill her and her daughter ("As soon as we arrived, the devils tried to take her away!"). She staged the death of her daughter. Judith is no longer a threat...
    4) A few years later, Judith decide to take revenge...
    The movie doesn't really explain what happened between 3) and 4). In fact, it is not really told in the book either... The two sisters probably lived half a life each (although Judith's missing finger might be difficult to hide).
    It's only after watching the excellent doc. on the DVD that I finally understood everything(?)
    Vincent
    ------------------

    AFI Top 100 Films Home Theater Forum Challenge

    AFI Movies Left To Watch: 34 33 32 31 30: Sound Of Music (3.5 out of 4)
     

Share This Page