Robert Ross
Agent
- Joined
- May 18, 2003
- Messages
- 48
I have a few DVDs that had a second release of some sort that either give it better A/V quality or different features and I'm trying to decide whether I should buy these new versions. It's a bit of hassle for me, because I'll need to try and sell my old versions first (prolly through half.com), and then buy the new versions (thus I'll take quite a money loss on all of them). So if it isn't worth going through this hassle, I'd rather not bother with it. Keep in mind I'm in the process of adding surround sound, so if the audio has been revamped to sound much better than I would definitely be interested in buying it.
The first title is the one I already have, and the second is the one I'm considering buying.
12 Monkeys: Collector's Edition = 12 Monkeys - DTS (I've heard nothing about the DTS version, curious as to how much better it sounds. I've already watched all of the extras on the CE and I doubt I'll watch them again)
Lawrence of Arabia: LE = Lawrence of Arabia - Superbit (Unless the A/V is extremely superior to the LE, I doubt I'll upgrade this title because I want the LE for it's collector's value and I don't keep 2 versions of the same movie in my collection)
Leon: The Professional = Leon - Superbit (I havn't found any reviews on the A/V of the superbit, but I'm sure it's excellent as usual, and since there are next to no extras on the orginal disc I will prolly upgrade this one)
Memento = Memento: LE (the extras for the LE didn't really seem all that appealing to me, I heard the commentary is boring, the menus are confusing, and I could care less about watching the scenes in the right order. so it all comes down to the A/V quality. is it that much better than the orginal release?)
Saving Private Ryan = Saving Private Ryan - DTS (I've heard nothing but good things about the DTS track, although I've heard some extras are taken out, but I can live without it)
T2: UE = T2: EE (I've pretty much watched all of the extras on the UE and doubt I'll watch them again, so how is the A/V on EE?)
X-Men = X-Men 1.5 (I know they added a bunch of extras to the 1.5, but havn't heard anything new about the A/V.)
Well that's all of em. Opinions from the people who have experienced both versions would be very helpful before I start posting some of the DVDs for sale.
The first title is the one I already have, and the second is the one I'm considering buying.
12 Monkeys: Collector's Edition = 12 Monkeys - DTS (I've heard nothing about the DTS version, curious as to how much better it sounds. I've already watched all of the extras on the CE and I doubt I'll watch them again)
Lawrence of Arabia: LE = Lawrence of Arabia - Superbit (Unless the A/V is extremely superior to the LE, I doubt I'll upgrade this title because I want the LE for it's collector's value and I don't keep 2 versions of the same movie in my collection)
Leon: The Professional = Leon - Superbit (I havn't found any reviews on the A/V of the superbit, but I'm sure it's excellent as usual, and since there are next to no extras on the orginal disc I will prolly upgrade this one)
Memento = Memento: LE (the extras for the LE didn't really seem all that appealing to me, I heard the commentary is boring, the menus are confusing, and I could care less about watching the scenes in the right order. so it all comes down to the A/V quality. is it that much better than the orginal release?)
Saving Private Ryan = Saving Private Ryan - DTS (I've heard nothing but good things about the DTS track, although I've heard some extras are taken out, but I can live without it)
T2: UE = T2: EE (I've pretty much watched all of the extras on the UE and doubt I'll watch them again, so how is the A/V on EE?)
X-Men = X-Men 1.5 (I know they added a bunch of extras to the 1.5, but havn't heard anything new about the A/V.)
Well that's all of em. Opinions from the people who have experienced both versions would be very helpful before I start posting some of the DVDs for sale.