- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,513
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
What a difference an encode makes.
Many people were thrilled to finally see John Ford's 1952 three-strip Technicolor classic, The Quiet Man arrive on Blu-ray several years ago via a sub-license to Olive.
The difference between that release, which was hailed by many, and the earlier DVD release were night and day, as the earlier master appeared to be produced for VHS distribution. It was that bad.
Now, we get a UK, ie. Region B release, and once again the ante has been raised.
Derived from the same master, the Eureka!, Masters of Cinema release gives the film, at least for those with high-end systems, a major upgrade.
An upgrade based seemingly solely upon the encode, which has been produced by David Mackenzie.
Grain structure now comes to the fore, for a tighter image, with more depth, and better black levels. To put it in the most simple terms, the new Blu, especially when up-rezzed to 4k, appears totally film-like.
Would the difference be enough to make me add a Region B player, if I didn't have one?
In this case, yes. The image can stand up to projection beautifully.
If you're viewing on a 50 inch LCD panel, you're fine with what you have.
Image - 4.5
Audio - 5
4k Up-rez - 4.5
Pass / Fail - Pass
Recommended
RAH
Many people were thrilled to finally see John Ford's 1952 three-strip Technicolor classic, The Quiet Man arrive on Blu-ray several years ago via a sub-license to Olive.
The difference between that release, which was hailed by many, and the earlier DVD release were night and day, as the earlier master appeared to be produced for VHS distribution. It was that bad.
Now, we get a UK, ie. Region B release, and once again the ante has been raised.
Derived from the same master, the Eureka!, Masters of Cinema release gives the film, at least for those with high-end systems, a major upgrade.
An upgrade based seemingly solely upon the encode, which has been produced by David Mackenzie.
Grain structure now comes to the fore, for a tighter image, with more depth, and better black levels. To put it in the most simple terms, the new Blu, especially when up-rezzed to 4k, appears totally film-like.
Would the difference be enough to make me add a Region B player, if I didn't have one?
In this case, yes. The image can stand up to projection beautifully.
If you're viewing on a 50 inch LCD panel, you're fine with what you have.
Image - 4.5
Audio - 5
4k Up-rez - 4.5
Pass / Fail - Pass
Recommended
RAH