- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,424
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
Sherlock Homes - A Game of Shadows is a beautifully produced disc.
Shot on film in S35 format, and taken through a 2k DI on its way back to final theatrical formats, it just looks right.
Watching the film, my mind kept visiting The Big Sleep, as I found a major similarity in the story lines. Absolute confusion.
Of course, half way through SH - GoS, things finally begin to spin into shape, while TBS just meandered in its own way, rather like a stream finding its own banks through a wilderness.
In the end, I got it, and while I found it entertaining, I did not feel it was in league with the first entry into the series.
Audio, and please don't take this as gospel, as I need to go back and check against other discs, seemed a bit boomy, with dialogue not as crisp and clean as I might have preferred, but there were no real problems.
Overall, Warner's new release is a nice addition to the Holmes canon, especially since it stands to great extent in opposition to the far more quiet and fully entertaining BBC series.
A good film, not a great one, on a quality Blu-ray disc.
Recommended.
RAH
Shot on film in S35 format, and taken through a 2k DI on its way back to final theatrical formats, it just looks right.
Watching the film, my mind kept visiting The Big Sleep, as I found a major similarity in the story lines. Absolute confusion.
Of course, half way through SH - GoS, things finally begin to spin into shape, while TBS just meandered in its own way, rather like a stream finding its own banks through a wilderness.
In the end, I got it, and while I found it entertaining, I did not feel it was in league with the first entry into the series.
Audio, and please don't take this as gospel, as I need to go back and check against other discs, seemed a bit boomy, with dialogue not as crisp and clean as I might have preferred, but there were no real problems.
Overall, Warner's new release is a nice addition to the Holmes canon, especially since it stands to great extent in opposition to the far more quiet and fully entertaining BBC series.
A good film, not a great one, on a quality Blu-ray disc.
Recommended.
RAH