Craig Rosenthal
Agent
- Joined
- Aug 12, 1999
- Messages
- 28
Here's a brief mini-review of the DV-45A, mostly about its bass management capabilities. Before going into details, let me just say that I think that my quest is over... but I still have another 6 days on my 7 day return policy to be sure...
My quest was for SACD and progressive DVD; DVD-Audio was a very nice and wanted bonus, but given the limited amount of machines out there, I wasn't too hopeful. My primary concern with most of the players that I have experimented with was their bass management capabilities, since I want to set all my speakers as small and get my low bass from my Velodyne sub.
Video:
On the video side, as expected it does demonstrate the chroma-error. I've only seen it in the "Elektra Records" intro clips to some of the DVD-A discs, not during the few movies that I've tried. I'm going to try some more discs, but I didn't see anything wrong with the panic-button scene of the Fifth Element. Unless it starts manifesting itself in noticeable places in regular program material, I'm going to live with it. Overall video quality is very good, about on par with what I remember the Panasonic RP-62 delivering (don't still have the RP-62 around to compare with), and much sharper with the DVP-NS755V that I returned because the video was too soft.
Audio:
From what I can tell, bass redirection appears to work in all modes. All two channel sources (I tried CD, MP3, DVD-A and SACD) seem to redirect the bass correctly to the subwoofer. Same with multi-channel DVD-A and SACD; bass appears to be redirected to the sub. So far, this was a weakness of any of the Sony SACD players that I tried - they either didn't redirect the bass to the sub (DVP-NS500V) or appeared to leave a hole in the music (SCD-775 - possibly due to the high 120hz crossover). I don't know the specific crossover frequency, but it appears to integrate my sub and my other speakers nicely.
I can't really test the time-alignment feature, but there is a note that I came across on page 50 of the manual that states that the speaker distance settings don't apply to SACD sources (but the channel levels do). While literally that would imply that the distance settings apply to DVD-A, we all know how much we can trust owner's manuals to precisely cover highly technical details.
Preliminarily, sound quality on DVD-A and SACD seem quite good (I never heard DVD-A before, but the Doors - LA Woman and Fleetwood Mac - Rumors sound very nice). I am listening to Billy Joel - 52nd Street now, and I am enjoying the multi-channel track (although I am still not crazy about instruments being placed in the surrounds). Regular CDs sound quite good as well – I listened to the Eagles Hell Freezes Over, and was very pleased.
Craig
My quest was for SACD and progressive DVD; DVD-Audio was a very nice and wanted bonus, but given the limited amount of machines out there, I wasn't too hopeful. My primary concern with most of the players that I have experimented with was their bass management capabilities, since I want to set all my speakers as small and get my low bass from my Velodyne sub.
Video:
On the video side, as expected it does demonstrate the chroma-error. I've only seen it in the "Elektra Records" intro clips to some of the DVD-A discs, not during the few movies that I've tried. I'm going to try some more discs, but I didn't see anything wrong with the panic-button scene of the Fifth Element. Unless it starts manifesting itself in noticeable places in regular program material, I'm going to live with it. Overall video quality is very good, about on par with what I remember the Panasonic RP-62 delivering (don't still have the RP-62 around to compare with), and much sharper with the DVP-NS755V that I returned because the video was too soft.
Audio:
From what I can tell, bass redirection appears to work in all modes. All two channel sources (I tried CD, MP3, DVD-A and SACD) seem to redirect the bass correctly to the subwoofer. Same with multi-channel DVD-A and SACD; bass appears to be redirected to the sub. So far, this was a weakness of any of the Sony SACD players that I tried - they either didn't redirect the bass to the sub (DVP-NS500V) or appeared to leave a hole in the music (SCD-775 - possibly due to the high 120hz crossover). I don't know the specific crossover frequency, but it appears to integrate my sub and my other speakers nicely.
I can't really test the time-alignment feature, but there is a note that I came across on page 50 of the manual that states that the speaker distance settings don't apply to SACD sources (but the channel levels do). While literally that would imply that the distance settings apply to DVD-A, we all know how much we can trust owner's manuals to precisely cover highly technical details.
Preliminarily, sound quality on DVD-A and SACD seem quite good (I never heard DVD-A before, but the Doors - LA Woman and Fleetwood Mac - Rumors sound very nice). I am listening to Billy Joel - 52nd Street now, and I am enjoying the multi-channel track (although I am still not crazy about instruments being placed in the surrounds). Regular CDs sound quite good as well – I listened to the Eagles Hell Freezes Over, and was very pleased.
Craig