felix_suwarno
Screenwriter
- Joined
- Dec 2, 2001
- Messages
- 1,523
ok, i am looking for speakers that :
- look good, and i prefer white maple / cherry wood finish
- the drivers have to be at least 5.25 inch in diameter, but i do prefer 6 inch ( for surround speakers )
- i also need the bookshelf speakers to have floorstanding counterpart.
so i went to a few shops and auditioned these bookshelf speakers :
( i used these cds : guns n roses "sweet child of mine" and emi fujita's songs )
dynaudio contour 1.1 $850
dynaudio audience 4.2 $550
i auditioned these two back to back. i noticed slightly clearer highs and slightly fuller bass on the contour, but somehow i do believe that was just my ears and my mind only, knowing that the contour 1.1 was more expensive = should be better theoretically. i dont think it is worth to pay 300 dollar more for the contour.
jamo ( 6 inch driver, i forgot to ask which type )
sounds full, warm, smooth and everything, but the cabinet looked ugly to me. i thought i heard pronounced "ssss" sound on emi fujita's voice, but it turned out the same "ssss" sound also heard on other speakers. i didnt have the chance to do a back to back audition with another speaker.
atc ( dunno which type ), not new speakers ( used ), but also the most expensive at $1100. i hated these ones. very harsh, no "airy effect".
sonus faber ( dunno which type ), not new, and i auditioned these back to back with the atc speakers. i didnt have any intention to auditioned these two, actually. but i thought i should opened my mind about different brands, so i gave them a try. that is why i didnt really pay attention to the speaker's code / name. and these bookshelves were the worst i heard today. harsh! no clear separation between the voice and the music instrument. muddy at best.
monitor audio bronze ( the smallest one ). i originally wanted to audition monitor audio gold bookshelves. but the store didnt have them, they only had the bronze ones. and these speakers sounded REALLY GOOD to me. and they were also the cheapest ones at $350. smooth, nice, not too bright, not too warm, just perfect. if the cheapest one is this good, i am dying to hear the gold ones.
i didnt really pay attention to the receiver/amps used. currently, at home i have boston acoustics vr-m50 and vr-mc for the fronts and psb image 1b for the rears. in the office i have paradigm cinema cc70 all around.
now i think there is something wrong with my ears.
i had never done auditioning like this before. how come my ears prefer the cheapest of them all?? i really wanted to be very objective with my opinion, that is why i come this forum asking for advice.
what do i have to look / hear in auditioning process? specific part? how come i didnt really notice noticeable improvement between the dynaudios? are my ears normal? is there any specific song i should bring with me to audition these speakers?
honestly, i do think my bostons are really good. i dont feel the need to upgrade to these speakers because i didnt really notice significant improvement over my current system. but i am really curious about the monitor audio's gold speakers...
advice please.
( oh these shop owners kept telling me about how good their expensive wires are compared to some other brands. one of the wire brand costed about 25 dollar per 3 1/3 feet. i simply ignored them about this matter )
- look good, and i prefer white maple / cherry wood finish
- the drivers have to be at least 5.25 inch in diameter, but i do prefer 6 inch ( for surround speakers )
- i also need the bookshelf speakers to have floorstanding counterpart.
so i went to a few shops and auditioned these bookshelf speakers :
( i used these cds : guns n roses "sweet child of mine" and emi fujita's songs )
dynaudio contour 1.1 $850
dynaudio audience 4.2 $550
i auditioned these two back to back. i noticed slightly clearer highs and slightly fuller bass on the contour, but somehow i do believe that was just my ears and my mind only, knowing that the contour 1.1 was more expensive = should be better theoretically. i dont think it is worth to pay 300 dollar more for the contour.
jamo ( 6 inch driver, i forgot to ask which type )
sounds full, warm, smooth and everything, but the cabinet looked ugly to me. i thought i heard pronounced "ssss" sound on emi fujita's voice, but it turned out the same "ssss" sound also heard on other speakers. i didnt have the chance to do a back to back audition with another speaker.
atc ( dunno which type ), not new speakers ( used ), but also the most expensive at $1100. i hated these ones. very harsh, no "airy effect".
sonus faber ( dunno which type ), not new, and i auditioned these back to back with the atc speakers. i didnt have any intention to auditioned these two, actually. but i thought i should opened my mind about different brands, so i gave them a try. that is why i didnt really pay attention to the speaker's code / name. and these bookshelves were the worst i heard today. harsh! no clear separation between the voice and the music instrument. muddy at best.
monitor audio bronze ( the smallest one ). i originally wanted to audition monitor audio gold bookshelves. but the store didnt have them, they only had the bronze ones. and these speakers sounded REALLY GOOD to me. and they were also the cheapest ones at $350. smooth, nice, not too bright, not too warm, just perfect. if the cheapest one is this good, i am dying to hear the gold ones.
i didnt really pay attention to the receiver/amps used. currently, at home i have boston acoustics vr-m50 and vr-mc for the fronts and psb image 1b for the rears. in the office i have paradigm cinema cc70 all around.
now i think there is something wrong with my ears.
i had never done auditioning like this before. how come my ears prefer the cheapest of them all?? i really wanted to be very objective with my opinion, that is why i come this forum asking for advice.
what do i have to look / hear in auditioning process? specific part? how come i didnt really notice noticeable improvement between the dynaudios? are my ears normal? is there any specific song i should bring with me to audition these speakers?
honestly, i do think my bostons are really good. i dont feel the need to upgrade to these speakers because i didnt really notice significant improvement over my current system. but i am really curious about the monitor audio's gold speakers...
advice please.
( oh these shop owners kept telling me about how good their expensive wires are compared to some other brands. one of the wire brand costed about 25 dollar per 3 1/3 feet. i simply ignored them about this matter )