Jim C
Second Unit
- Joined
- Jul 7, 2001
- Messages
- 272
Originally Posted by crumbs
So there's no new deleted material from Alien3? Not even the original Newt Autopsy scene they spent 5 minutes discussing in the documentary?
What a shame. There's LOTS of material left from that film sitting in storage boxes, including the single most important scene David Fincher fought to the last breath to keep in the film, but wasn't able to. That being Ripley's final struggle with Bishop at the end of the film, an incredible acting moment for Sigourney. A 40+ second shot of Ripley's emotional torment deciding between turning herself over to Bishop, or sacrificing herself and the Alien within. It's the emotional climax of the entire *trilogy* and (for people who don't really care for Resurrection) the character Ripley. All she's fought for in the first three films comes down to that single moment, and Fincher has always said if there was one single scene he wish was still in the final cut, that was it. It was in the Workprint the SE was based off, too!
It's disappointing such a simple addition couldn't be made. Would have made a near-flawless Special Edition, if they were truly trying to release a version of the film 'as close to Fincher's original vision as possible.' So why is it missing the one scene he lamented losing more than any other? As far as I know, it's the only deleted scene he's discussed openly, so it must have had significance for him. Even as a bonus on the 5th or 6th discs would have been a really nice gesture for fans buying these films for the 3rd or 4th time.
Great post crumbs - I completely agree with everything you have said How that 40 second scene never made the 2003 Assembly Cut is just beyond me. It is without doubt the most important scene of the whole film - shamelessly left on the cutting room floor in 1992 thanks to a group of studio execs who thought they knew better. The entire film builds to that one moment alone, and I can see why Fincher fought so strongly for it's inclusion. It's a scene that really needs to be reinstated to it's rightful place imho.
This may well be just wishful thinking on my part, but hopefully some of the deleted material that never made the 2003 Assembly Cut will appear in the new Wreckage & Rage doc on the 5th disc. I believe this version has an additional hour of footage that never made it onto the edited Quad version, so there maybe hope yet. In addition, there are the Enhancement Pods on disc 5, and I believe these have a total running time of an hour for the Alien 3 related ones. It really will be such a shame if the deleted material doesn't show up on this new set in one form or another.