Ok, I will admit, it's been a good while since I have read the book this film is based on. Let me get the obvious out of the way: Winslet and DiCaprio are very good in their roles, and the camera work in the film is great.
However, the movie itself is hard to take because it's one of those things that as a book works, but as a film tends to lay there. The problem is that in a book form you can tell a free-flowing story but it just doesn't translate to the screen.
About half way through, my wife & I were pretty sure that Winslet's character suffered from bipolar disorder; something neither of us really remembered from the book, but she had all the characeristics in the movie. Mood swings, disorientation, etc. It made Leo's character one you would normally sympathize with, but his dialog and movement leaves you going "blah".
I'm a big fan of Mendes, who is slowly building a very enviable career. This is one of those films that will get some high praise.. and some significant negatives, I think.
Opens in art houses (limited) tomorrow. And I will say this: see this in a theater if you're a fan; there are moments that are hard to imagine on the small screen because of how the camera movement works. When/if you see it, you'll understand. It's such subtle but graceful movement - that all of the scenes in the external forest remind me of Kubrick's 2001.
:star: :star: :star: :star: / :star: :star: :star: :star: :star:
However, the movie itself is hard to take because it's one of those things that as a book works, but as a film tends to lay there. The problem is that in a book form you can tell a free-flowing story but it just doesn't translate to the screen.
About half way through, my wife & I were pretty sure that Winslet's character suffered from bipolar disorder; something neither of us really remembered from the book, but she had all the characeristics in the movie. Mood swings, disorientation, etc. It made Leo's character one you would normally sympathize with, but his dialog and movement leaves you going "blah".
I'm a big fan of Mendes, who is slowly building a very enviable career. This is one of those films that will get some high praise.. and some significant negatives, I think.
Opens in art houses (limited) tomorrow. And I will say this: see this in a theater if you're a fan; there are moments that are hard to imagine on the small screen because of how the camera movement works. When/if you see it, you'll understand. It's such subtle but graceful movement - that all of the scenes in the external forest remind me of Kubrick's 2001.
:star: :star: :star: :star: / :star: :star: :star: :star: :star: