-Not Logged In-

Jump to content

Sign up for a free account to remove the pop-up ads

Signing up for an account is fast and free. As a member you can join in the conversation, enter contests and remove the pop-up ads that guests get. Click here to create your free account.

- - - - -


Blu-ray Reviews

  • You cannot start a new topic
  • Please log in to reply
35 replies to this topic

#1 of 36 OFFLINE   Michael Osadciw

Michael Osadciw


  • 1,329 posts
  • Join Date: Jun 24 2003
  • Real Name:Michael Osadciw

Posted March 22 2008 - 12:33 PM

Blu-ray Disc Review


Distributor: Warner Bros.
Original Release: 2007
Original Length: 100 min
Alternate Version: 104 min
Genre: Sci-Fi/Horror/Drama
Film Rating: PG-13

Aspect Ratio: 2.35:1
Colour/B&W: Colour

BD Specifications:
Resolution: 1080/24p
Video Codec: AVC MPEG-4
Disc Size: BD-50

  • English Dolby TrueHD 5.1 Surround
  • English Dolby Digital 5.1 (default)
  • French (Quebec) Dolby Digital 5.1
  • Spanish (Latin) Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround

    Subtitles: English (ESDH), French, Latin Spanish

  • Release Date: March 18, 2007.

    Film Rating: Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image / Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image

    Starring: Will Smith (Robert Neville), Alice Braga (Anna), Charlie Tahan (Ethan), Salli Richardson (Zoe Neville), Willow Smith (Marley Neville)

    Screenplay by: Mark Protosevich & Akiva Goldsman
    Based on the novel by: Richard Matheson
    Directed by: Akiva Goldsman

    I Am Legend, a film so infectious at the box office earning more that $550 million worldwide, has come to the three home video formats, DVD, Blu-ray, and HD-DVD. All three releases are different to some degree in presentation of special features, but they all deliver an awesome audio and video home theater experience. Home Theater Forum’s reviewer Ken McAlinden has reviewed the DVD here, and following his synopsis within this review is my impressions of the Blu-ray disc’s performance.

    Ken McAlinden writes: I Am Legend is the third cinematic adaptation of Richard Matheson's 1954 novel of the same name. Preceded by the low budget 1964 Vincent Price film "The Last Man on Earth" and the 1971 Charlton Heston vehicle "The Omega Man", this latest adaptation is the first one to use the title of the original novel, but it still takes great liberties with the plot. Though, the basic premise remains intriguing and it is easy to see why filmmakers have been drawn to it multiple times. [28 Days Later, anyone? – Mike]

    Will Smith plays Dr. Robert Neville, a military scientist and a survivor of a viral pandemic initiated by a failed attempt at creating a cancer vaccine. He is apparently the only living man on the island of Manhattan. His days are filled with a disciplined routine of scavenging for food, working on a vaccine based on his own blood's immunity, and trying to contact any other survivors with only his dog as a companion. His nights are spent holed up in his Greenwich Village home in order to avoid marauding bands of "Dark Seekers". The Dark Seekers are a fraction of the humans who have been infected by the virus who lived but were mutated into bloodthirsty bad CGI effects with an aversion to ultraviolet radiation that prevents them from venturing outside during daylight hours.

    Smith gives perhaps the best performance of his career, and absolutely carries the first two-thirds of the film. He immerses himself in the character of Neville and is completely convincing in scenes with only limited amounts of dialog. To be completely honest, I did not know he had a performance like this in him, and did not expect so much from a genre film. In a few scenes, he exchanges dialog with mannequins and even makes them look good.

    Aside from its lead actor, the film's other strength is the combination of production design and special effects used to create an abandoned Manhattan. There is something downright eerie about seeing familiar Manhattan sites completely devoid of people, and the filmmakers clearly put a lot of though and effort into realizing this cinematically. Another impressive sequence happens in flashback as we see the evacuation and sealing off of Manhattan early during the outbreak of the viral pandemic.

    As spectacularly rendered as the film's vision of a post-apocalyptic Manhattan is, the special effects employed to render the Dark Seekers are a big disappointment. They look like the CGI demons that they are and never seem to belong in the same reality as the rest of the film frame in which they appear. The film would likely have worked better with actors in standard zombie-style make-up and cost less, too. I usually have a fair amount of tolerance for CGI beasties, but these are the most jarringly wrong looking movie creatures I have seen since Blarp from the 1998 Lost in Space adaptation. Whenever the Dark Seekers are lurking in the shadows, they are menacing and the film is working. As soon as you see them, the scene falls apart. [I couldn’t agree more. CGI may look good, but relying heavily on it for human-like creatures takes away from a truly frightening experience because they never do in fact look real. Of course, real actors cannot perform the ultra-human stunts that these CGI characters do. Maybe a combination of human faces on CGI bodies with the “less is more” approach would have worked better. – Mike].

    Setting that gripe aside, the film's final third is not quite as strong as what comes before it. The filmmakers devises a completely different ending than Matheson’s novel and either do not try to or just plain fail to capture the fatalistic spirit of the original story. All that comes before is strong enough that I still enjoyed the overall experience despite a whiff of disappointment.

    Did I say they devised a completely different ending than the novel? In fact, they devised two completely different endings than the novel. The second disc of this Two-Disc Special Edition includes an alternate version of the film that runs four minutes longer than the widely released theatrical cut. [The Blu-ray disc has the alternate version accessible via seamless branching. – Mike]. Billed somewhat prosaically as an "Alternate Theatrical Version", the only significant difference I noticed was the ending; it takes the story in a whole different direction. Without giving too much away, the widely released ending is more heroic whereas the alternate version has more of a cynical twist and also seems to be better foreshadowed by the events that preceded it. I did not have a strong preference for either one. [I much preferred the theatrical version’s darker ending. – Mike].

    Posted ImageVIDEO QUALITY: 5/5 Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image

    Warner Bros. continues to impress with their solid video presentations rendering all details for a reference quality video presentation. From the moment the film starts to the closing millisecond, I was suspended in disbelief. The detail delivered by the pristine source and extended resolution of the Blu-ray format is exceptional. Except for the CGI characters (eg. deer, lions, rats, and dark seekers), the real and CGI landscapes look awesome. Colours are naturally rendered in daytime scenes without looking oversaturated. Skin tones look fantastic and every white strand in Will Smith’s hair is clearly visible. The film relies heavily on sunlight and the darkness of night to create suspense. The warmth of dusk falls on New York without a sunburned appearance on everything in sight. Shades of darkness a delivered accurately, and I was especially impressed with the approaching darkness in the scene where Neville wakes up hanging upside down. It wasn’t too dark, and the feeling of the sun just falling below the horizon was done quite well. I was impressed even in the darkest scenes; when Neville looks for Sam in one of the buildings, the darkness created an immense sense of fear for the character and as a viewer. What lurks in there?

    I can’t say I have any complaints with the film’s image presentation. If I were to pick just one, in some dark scenes the black level has been lifted slightly (much like raising the “brightness” control on a television) to give you the impression of being able to see into the dark details a bit better. It’s possible that whoever was behind the controls thought the original photography was to dark and made the judgment call to raise black slightly in these shots.

    Posted ImageAUDIO QUALITY: 5/5 Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image

    From the most subtle breeze, the chirping of insects, and the rustling of paper across the abandoned roads, this sound design knows how to be quiet and when. It is contrasted with loud moments with the most intense action – mostly when the dark seekers are in the picture. All channels are engaged and the sound design is clear, neutral, and dynamic. Music is recorded wonderfully but dialogue is not always integrated well. Too often Will Smith’s voice had the environment of a recording booth rather than the acoustics of his bathroom. With all of the noise in the streets of New York during shooting, you can be sure that most of the dialogue was re-recorded. Thankfully the voice was sync’d with the lips. All channels are actively engaged almost all of the time. Sound effects are recorded and reproduced with precision. Only once was I disappointed: the helicopter scenes. While voices were (accurately) difficult to hear when being drowned out by the sounds of the blades cutting through the air, the loudness and the ambient realism of standing beside a helicopter just wasn’t there. It felt like the realism was held back, maybe intentionally, but I doubt it. The overall sound was a bit dry and sounded too much like the acoustics of a dubbing stage rather than out on the docks by the water. One day we’ll get close to realism!! The lossless Dolby TrueHD is the superior encoding.

    TACTILE FUN!! Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image / Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image

    If you have the opportunity to watch this film for the first time with a bass shaker or tactile transducer attached to your chair and wired only to the dedicated LFE channel, you are in for a treat. When dark seekers jump out of nowhere and there is full-on physical contact when fighting, you feel the wallop in your gut. You feel like you are a part of the fight. You feel like you are hit from behind. It’s wild! I can’t wait to scare people with this one.

    Posted ImageSPECIAL FEATURES: 2/5 Posted Image Posted Image

    The disc I received is Future Shop-exclusive steel book package. I’m not sure if any U.S. retail offers a similar exclusive package. Regardless, the discs all have similar content on them. What is available on DVD only by DVD-ROM is accessible as any other feature is on the Blu-ray disc, just without the downloading inconvenience. This is the Creating “I Am Legend" section of the disc that contains material just under an hour, all 16:9 enhanced SD. The snippets are:

  • Closing Down Fifth Avenue (5:48)
  • The Joy Ride Jump (4:54)
  • Will in the Driver's Seat (2.58)
  • Canine Co-Star (3:26)
  • NYC Gone Back to Nature (1:49)
  • Robert Neville's Psychology (2:03)
  • Quiet Imagination (2:15)
  • Evacuation, Part 1: Family Convoy (1:05)
  • Neville's Weapons (2:19)
  • That Scary Place Inside All of Us (1:53)
  • Shooting the Intrepid (1:35)
  • Building the Pier (2:31)
  • Evacuation, Part 2: Military Cooperation (2:02)
  • Will's Physical Training (2:18)
  • Creating the Dark Seekers (2:44)
  • Evacuation, Part 3: Choppers (1:42)
  • The Conflicts of Isolation (2:07)
  • Trusting the Unknown (2:19)
  • Will Smith in Action (1:44)

    Also accessible by a traditional menu is Cautionary Tale: The Science of “I Am Legend”. It's an HD featurette that runs 20 minutes and 41 seconds with available subtitles in English and French. It covers a number of topics relating to viral outbreaks, including Virus Research, Vaccines, Pandemics, HIV as a Case Study, Avian Flu, SARS as a Case Study, and Field Virologists Hunting for the Next Virus. It consists largely of on-camera interviews with occasional inserts of graphics. Strangely, it also contains a handful of clips from the 1995 film Outbreak. [also a Warner Bros. film. – Mike].

    Interview participants from the film's production include Will Smith, Francis Lawrence, and Writer/Producer Akiva Goldsman. The remainder of the participants consist of several doctors, authors, and academics specializing in the field of viruses including Julie L. Gerberding M.D., M.P.H. CDC; Dr. Nathan Wolfe, Professor of Epidemiology; Mary Elizabeth Wilson M.D. Harvard Medical School; Paul Rota, Ph. D. Microbiologist, Division of Viral Diseases, CDC; C.J. Peters, M.D. University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston; Dr. Eric Delwart Principal Investigator, Blood Systems Research Institute, UCSF; Dr. Anthony Fauci National Institute of Health; Linda Rosenstock, M.D., M.P.H.Dean, UCLA School of Public Health; Don Burke Dean, Graduate School of Public Health, University of Pittsburgh; Dr. Michael B.A. Oldstone The Scripps Research Institute; Laurie Garrett Author, The Coming PlagueDr. Michael B.A. Oldstone: Scripps Research Institute; Terrence Tumpey, Ph. D., Team Lead Microbiologist, Influenza Division, CDC; T.C. Ksiazek, D.V.M., Ph. D. Chief, Special Pathogens Branch, CDC; Paul Rota, Ph. D. Microbiologist, Division of Viral Diseases, CDC; C.J. Peters, M.D. University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston.

    The following four animated comics are also available in HD and have 2.0 stereo audio. As their description suggests, they appear to be a series of comic panels to which very limited animation touches are applied. Each tells a brief story about how the virus depicted in the film impacts peoples in different places around the globe. The titles, locations, and running times are as follows:

  • Death as a Gift [Hong Kong, China] (3:01)
  • Isolation [Colorado, USA] (6:35)
  • Sacrificing the Few for the Many [Central America] (3:27)
  • Shelter [New Delhi, India] (8:37)

    IN THE END...

    So the CGI was a bit of a bummer and both endings were somewhat unsatisfying, but that doesn’t bring down my experience of this film. I do recommend it for the film as well as the absolutely outstanding audio and video presentation.

    Michael Osadciw
    March 22, 2008.

    Review System

  • [PG]118373405[/PG]

    Michael Osadciw

    THX/ISF Professional Video Calibrator

    Video Contributor

    CANADA HiFi Magazine

    #2 of 36 OFFLINE   Ronald Epstein

    Ronald Epstein

      Studio Mogul

    • 44,085 posts
    • Join Date: Jul 03 1997

    Posted March 22 2008 - 08:21 PM

    Thank you for the review, Mike. One of the initial reasons why I chose not to purchase this title was because when announced, it seemed that the alternative ending was not included. Granted, this could have been limited to the HD-DVD release. According to your review the alternative ending is included. This may prompt an immediate purchase.


    Ronald J Epstein
    Home Theater Forum co-owner


     Click Here for the latest/hottest Blu-ray Preorders  Click Here for our complete Blu-ray review archive

     Click Here for our complete 3D Blu-ray review archive Click Here for our complete DVD review archive

     Click Here for Blu-Ray Preorder Release Schedule  Click Here for forum posting rules and regulations

    #3 of 36 OFFLINE   Robert Crawford

    Robert Crawford


    • 27,407 posts
    • Join Date: Dec 09 1998
    • Real Name:Robert
    • LocationMichigan

    Posted March 22 2008 - 08:28 PM

    I liked this film better than most that have read the book so I'm looking forward to my copy's arrival. Furthermore, I can't wait until I see the alternate ending. I was never a big fan of "Omega Man", though I own the BR disc of it. That's not to say I didn't enjoy it just that it isn't one of my favorite films of that genre. I feel the same about "The Last Man on Earth" that I have on SD DVD. I think neither film has the acting performance that Smith delivers in this latest version of this written material. However, you're right about one thing, the CGI was horrible which hurts the film to a degree and probably affected the reviews of others about this film. Crawdaddy

    #4 of 36 OFFLINE   Tino


      Lead Actor

    • 6,637 posts
    • Join Date: Apr 19 1999
    • Real Name:Valentino
    • LocationMetro NYC

    Posted March 22 2008 - 11:35 PM

    The cautionary tale extra IS in HD btw.
    It's gonna be a hell of a ride. I'm ready. .

    #5 of 36 OFFLINE   Douglas Monce

    Douglas Monce


    • 5,514 posts
    • Join Date: Nov 16 2006

    Posted March 23 2008 - 12:25 AM

    Oh come on there is nothing quite like a good early 70s doomsday sci-fi flick starring Chuck Heston!

    Can you say guilty pleasure? Posted Image

    "I'm in great shape, for the shape I'm in."
    Bob Hope in The Ghostbreakers

    #6 of 36 OFFLINE   Jim_K


      Executive Producer

    • 10,090 posts
    • Join Date: Apr 07 2000

    Posted March 23 2008 - 12:46 AM

    I have to say I went in with a tad bit of low expectations and was pleasantly surprised. While it's not even near a perfect adaptation (I've given up that there ever will be) and add the fact that the concept isn't exactly fresh anymore as it's been ripped off so frequently over the years by Romero and his imitators, Boyle, etc, etc. I'd say Smith's performance (it's amazing what he can do without the usual one-liners) brought the film to a higher level. It was a worthy blind-buy for me.
    Death before Streaming!

    #7 of 36 OFFLINE   Matt Hough

    Matt Hough

      Executive Producer

    • 13,294 posts
    • Join Date: Apr 24 2006
    • LocationCharlotte, NC

    Posted March 23 2008 - 01:46 AM

    It was a blind buy for me, too. Just couldn't pass up Amazon's amazing price reduction on this title. (I wish they'd do it with MICHAEL CLAYTON.) I was very pleasantly surprised by how effective it was (I jumped in my chair several times) and how fresh it seemed even though I reviewed the BD of THE OMEGA MAN just a month or so ago. The CGI was the weak link to be sure, but otherwise, I found it an entertaining popcorn movie and one I'll revisit with pleasure.

    #8 of 36 OFFLINE   Michael Osadciw

    Michael Osadciw


    • 1,329 posts
    • Join Date: Jun 24 2003
    • Real Name:Michael Osadciw

    Posted March 23 2008 - 02:14 AM

    CGI is certainly weak when viewing in HD. I think the HD medium will put even more demands on CGI technology. Jim - I also agree that it's great to see Smith in a performance without one-liners. I hate one liners...

    Michael Osadciw

    THX/ISF Professional Video Calibrator

    Video Contributor

    CANADA HiFi Magazine

    #9 of 36 OFFLINE   Mike Frezon

    Mike Frezon

      Studio Mogul

    • 34,792 posts
    • Join Date: Oct 09 2001
    • LocationRensselaer, NY

    Posted March 23 2008 - 08:06 AM

    I also did a blind buy of this disc because of amazon's great price. Hopefully their sales of this title @ $18.95 will encourage similar pricing schemes in the future.

    It is still on its way to me...but I am very much looking forward to it.

    Thanks for the review, Michael (and Ken)! I like this tag team approach to reviews! What's next...steel cage matches!?! Posted Image

    There's Jessie the yodeling cowgirl. Bullseye, he's Woody's horse. Pete the old prospector. And, Woody, the man himself.Of course, it's time for Woody's RoundUp. He's the very best! He's the rootinest, tootinest cowboy in the wild, wild west!

    HTF Rules | HTF Mission Statement | Father of the Bride

    Faithfully Yours -- the new book by Peggy Frezon

    #10 of 36 OFFLINE   Joseph J.D

    Joseph J.D


    • 2,695 posts
    • Join Date: Dec 04 2001

    Posted March 23 2008 - 03:07 PM

    I enjoyed this film in IMAX and I am especially looking forward to seeing this again. I also picked up the Future Shop steelbook case which must be the first ever specialty case in this format....pretty neat looking too. In regards to watching this film on Blu-ray, I'm really looking forward to the scene where:
    Neville and his dog Sam are hiding in the bathtub at home as the dark seekers start prowling around at nightfall. I remember feeling quite unnerved by that sequence.....I hope it's just as effective on Blu-ray as it was on the IMAX sound system.

    Recently watched- The Masque Of The Red Death(1964), Sabotage(2014), Twin Peaks: Season 1, The Pit and The Pendulum(1961), Beware The Batman: Shadows Of Gotham, Scream and Scream Again, Arrow: Season 3, The Return Of Count Yorga, Count Yorga,Vampire, John Carpenter's Vampires, Burn Notice: Season 7, V For Vendetta, Halloween: Resurrection

    Currently watching- Planet Earth, True Blood: Season 3, Gatchaman: The Complete Series, Tales From The Crypt: Season 2, Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D.: Season 1, Game Of Thrones: Season 2, Heroes: Season 2, The Pacific, Battlestar Galactica: The Definitive Collection, Beware The Batman: Dark Justice, Twin Peaks: The Entire Mystery, Scarecrow & Mrs. King: Season 2
    "The owls are not what they seem."


    #11 of 36 OFFLINE   Duane Robinson

    Duane Robinson

      Second Unit

    • 347 posts
    • Join Date: Mar 26 2001

    Posted March 24 2008 - 04:18 AM

    Like the review said, the first two-thirds of the movie are pretty great. Once the Dark Seekers are revealed, the rest of the movie sort of falls apart for me. Didn't really like the ending and they didn't expand enough on the progress of the creatures. I actually liked the documentary on viruses more than the actual film. One of the few special features I've watched in a long time.
    In the end only the fittest survive in this world. If you are strong you live...and if you are weak you die. I am the one who deserves to live. - Shishio Makoto

    What's really gonna make your noodle limp is when you realize that Thomas Anderson is an anagram for "No Modern Asshat".
    Deep... -...

    #12 of 36 OFFLINE   Bleddyn Williams

    Bleddyn Williams

      Supporting Actor

    • 979 posts
    • Join Date: Dec 31 1969
    • Real Name:Bleddyn Williams

    Posted March 24 2008 - 04:27 AM

    Blind buy for me. Did enjoy, and preferred the alternate ending. Could someone familiar with the book post that ending here, preferably with spoiler tags?

    #13 of 36 OFFLINE   Paul Arnette

    Paul Arnette


    • 2,616 posts
    • Join Date: Jul 16 2002

    Posted March 24 2008 - 04:44 AM

    I would agree, but unfortunately it makes the third act's shortcomings all the more difficult for me to bear. Alas, two-thirds of a good movie does not a purchase make for me no matter how good a price or reference material it may be.
    Universal Blu-ray Discs I will not be buying while they're offered only as Blu-ray + DVD 'flipper' discs:

    The Jackal
    , Out of Africa, and Traffic.

    #14 of 36 OFFLINE   Ron-P



    • 6,285 posts
    • Join Date: Jul 25 2000
    • Real Name:Ron

    Posted March 24 2008 - 06:10 AM

    The presentation of this was great, some very good surround effects. Also, the alternate ending was so much better. What was really poor were the special effects of the zombies, some of the worst I've seen in a film in the past decade. Too bad, if they'd have gone with less CGI effects and more real-life stand in zombies, it would have helped make the film more believable and more enjoyable to watch. The zombies were nothing but a distraction for me they were so poorly done.
    You have all the weapons you need...Now fight!

    #15 of 36 OFFLINE   Sean Bryan

    Sean Bryan

      Sean Bryan

    • 3,287 posts
    • Join Date: Dec 31 1969
    • Real Name:Sean

    Posted March 24 2008 - 11:17 AM

    not zombies .... zompires!
    I don't believe in transcending the genre, I believe IN the genre - Joss Whedon

    #16 of 36 OFFLINE   Michael Osadciw

    Michael Osadciw


    • 1,329 posts
    • Join Date: Jun 24 2003
    • Real Name:Michael Osadciw

    Posted March 24 2008 - 01:20 PM

    flying CGI dark seekers that twist and turn like gumby is a poor decision in filmmaking.

    Michael Osadciw

    THX/ISF Professional Video Calibrator

    Video Contributor

    CANADA HiFi Magazine

    #17 of 36 OFFLINE   Bleddyn Williams

    Bleddyn Williams

      Supporting Actor

    • 979 posts
    • Join Date: Dec 31 1969
    • Real Name:Bleddyn Williams

    Posted March 25 2008 - 01:34 AM

    Thanks for the book ending, Paul!

    #18 of 36 OFFLINE   Paul Arnette

    Paul Arnette


    • 2,616 posts
    • Join Date: Jul 16 2002

    Posted March 25 2008 - 01:38 AM

    No problem. It is one of my favorite books. Techically, it is a novella, as it is only approx. 160 pages. I would recommend everyone read it; however it may hamper ones ability to enjoy The Omega Man, I Am Legend, and The Last Man on Earth (and probably in that order) in the process. Posted Image

    Edited to add:

    I forgot to mention one important detail about the novella's ending, which I have added to the spoiler above.
    Universal Blu-ray Discs I will not be buying while they're offered only as Blu-ray + DVD 'flipper' discs:

    The Jackal
    , Out of Africa, and Traffic.

    #19 of 36 OFFLINE   Dave H

    Dave H


    • 5,404 posts
    • Join Date: Aug 13 2000

    Posted March 25 2008 - 03:28 AM

    I saw this in the theater and thought it was pretty good - I felt the first hour was MUCH better than the last half hour - but I'll give it a rental sometime.

    #20 of 36 OFFLINE   Neil Joseph

    Neil Joseph

      Lead Actor

    • 8,341 posts
    • Join Date: Jan 16 1998
    • Real Name:Neil Joseph

    Posted March 25 2008 - 03:32 PM

    I love this film, the disk and the fact that both endings are on it. They both have a totally different flavour from each other but I like both. Does not hurt that the a/v is great too. Thanks for the review.
    Click and enter " T H E . H O L O D E C K "
    My Home Theatre "The Holodeck"


    Also tagged with one or more of these keywords: Blu-ray Reviews

    0 user(s) are reading this topic

    0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users