Richard_Gregory
Second Unit
- Joined
- Aug 31, 2005
- Messages
- 361
Daft idea. Lots of problems.
First, it means you'll have to go to a store with a specific movie in mind. You won't be browsing the shelves...the stores won't like that much. Unless the idea is to have empty cases with display art. What does this save the stores, and how does it match against the extra costs implied by the below?
Second, it still takes time to burn a DVD, even using the fastest writers.
Third, it implies a huge centralised store of movies, and a very high capacity network going out to the stores. A multi-gigabyte download is still significant. Unless they mean that stores will keep the movies in a local server.
Fourth, I wouldn't trust DVD writeable media for a permanent purchase. There are most definitely issues of reliability and longevity for these dye based discs. It makes you wonder what quality of media the stores would be using; top-notch discs with Tayo Yuden dyes, or cheap and nasty stuff (I think I can guess). Also these discs are less tolerant of handling than the usual stamped variety.
Lastly, why not just offer the service direct to home? I can't see that having a store do this for you offers significant advantages over buying a standard DVD in said store. But enabling people to download and burn their own discs at home does (no trip to a store, no mail ordering and waiting, etc).
I think, if this idea was so good, they'd have already done it with CD's. That technology has been with us for some time. I don't think there are stores where you go and choose your music and have it burnt to a CD while you wait..?
First, it means you'll have to go to a store with a specific movie in mind. You won't be browsing the shelves...the stores won't like that much. Unless the idea is to have empty cases with display art. What does this save the stores, and how does it match against the extra costs implied by the below?
Second, it still takes time to burn a DVD, even using the fastest writers.
Third, it implies a huge centralised store of movies, and a very high capacity network going out to the stores. A multi-gigabyte download is still significant. Unless they mean that stores will keep the movies in a local server.
Fourth, I wouldn't trust DVD writeable media for a permanent purchase. There are most definitely issues of reliability and longevity for these dye based discs. It makes you wonder what quality of media the stores would be using; top-notch discs with Tayo Yuden dyes, or cheap and nasty stuff (I think I can guess). Also these discs are less tolerant of handling than the usual stamped variety.
Lastly, why not just offer the service direct to home? I can't see that having a store do this for you offers significant advantages over buying a standard DVD in said store. But enabling people to download and burn their own discs at home does (no trip to a store, no mail ordering and waiting, etc).
I think, if this idea was so good, they'd have already done it with CD's. That technology has been with us for some time. I don't think there are stores where you go and choose your music and have it burnt to a CD while you wait..?