Professor Echo
Senior HTF Member
Not even just a few words about KING OF KINGS, THE GREATEST STORY EVER TOLD or THE BIBLE?
Why has he forsaken us?
Why has he forsaken us?
/forum/thread/310374/where-s-robert-harris-when-you-need-him#post_3797981Originally Posted by Professor Echo
Originally Posted by eric scott richard
When I saw King of Kings on TCM a few years back, I compared it to the dvd. TCM presented it in a 2.20 ratio and there was fair amount more on top/bottom and a lot less on the sides. I wonder what elements were used for the blu-ray? It looks spectacular, but I'm just wondering about the ratio.
Originally Posted by Professor Echo
Originally Posted by OliverK
I am pretty sure he would give both the Bible and King of Kings a recommended or highly recommended and TGSET a resounding FAIL of more or less Spartacus proportions.
I have seen two reviews for TGSET that give it 3/5 which would indicate it is still passable but from what I can see they used the old HD master that I have had the displeasure to check out recently and even factoring in that it might look a tad better on Blu-Ray because of the higher bitrate and less compression the more appropriate rating for TGSET would be around 2 out of 5 if we want to stay within the context of a score system.
Originally Posted by Robert Crawford
With all due respect to RAH, those of us that have viewed the King of Kings blu-ray, really don't need RAH to confirm what an excellent presentation it is. Furthermore, those that haven't viewed the BRD can read the many positive reviews across the internet about it from reviewers and non-reviewers. The opposite can be said about The Greatest Story Ever Told BRD.
Crawdaddy
Originally Posted by OliverK
Very true Robert, I was just answering to the original post of Professor Echo.
The feedback for KoK is very positive everywhere even where it isn't at other times. The screencaps look nice, too and everybody seems to be happy. Now don't get me started about TGSET though....
Originally Posted by Professor Echo
With all due respect to other reviews by critics/consumers, most of which I do reference and consider, I still appreciate and invest in Robert Harris' expertise for titles of this caliber and specifically from this era.
It's not necessarily as a buying guide, but as intellectual curiosity. As I previously posted, I may not always concur with his critical judgments, but his extensive technical knowledge of film history is both learned and comprehensive. Seeking his professional investigations and examinations toward same should not indicate any lack of research or confidence in other sources.
Originally Posted by Professor Echo
My request was simple and polite and intentionally humorous and certainly did not impose any obligation on anyone. This thread could just as easily faded away without any input of any kind from Robert Harris or anyone. I am grateful that he did choose to respond at least in part and gave us a mini-review for one of the titles I asked about. Thank you.
Originally Posted by Robert Harris
Just to chime in. I've had a chance to spot check King of Kings, and it looks precisely as it should. This is a project that should have been a simple image harvest toward the creation of an HD master. Beautiful disc.
I have not yet seen either GSET or Bible.
What is it with religion and April?
RAH
Originally Posted by Robert Crawford /forum/thread/310374/where-s-robert-harris-when-you-need-him#post_3798291
Originally Posted by Professor Echo
My request was simple and polite and intentionally humorous and certainly did not impose any obligation on anyone. This thread could just as easily faded away without any input of any kind from Robert Harris or anyone. I am grateful that he did choose to respond at least in part and gave us a mini-review for one of the titles I asked about. Thank you.