Jason_V
Senior HTF Member
Originally Posted by Bob_S. /t/321396/ten-favorite-star-trek-tos-episodes/30#post_3938002
One thing I've noticed: A Piece of the Action never seemed to be that popular let alone in anyone's top ten - until Star Trek IV came out. Then it seemed more and more fans were putting that in their top ten. I'm guessing since ST:IV had alot of humor in it and POTA was kind of similar? I've never cared for too much humor in Star Trek. That might be one of the reasons why ST:IV is my least favorite ST movie.
Speaking only for me, A Piece of the Action is fun, but it's the Star Trek characters playing dress up. There's not a lot there to connect it to the overall continuity...which is fine, don't get me wrong. Every episode/adventure doesn't have to feed into the universe to be enjoyable. We've just gotten through all three seasons of TOS on BD and the ONLY episode the BF fell asleep through-twice-was Piece of the Action. I had no interest in watching it three times in a week, so I stopped a fourth viewing. (And since it doesn't mean anything down the road, what's the point?)
As for Trek IV, it is the most accessible of all the movies. You don't need to know a whole lot to understand what's going on and a majority of the movie takes place in present-day Earth. I'd guess that's why it's the most popular. I agree with you on the movie itself, though: I don't think it's very good and certainly not my favorite of the series. It's Star Trek does Greenpeace and tends to be very preachy...topical is the word I'm looking for, I think. Trek VI is topical because of the end of the Cold War, the Berlin Wall and those events, but it's no where near the "in your face" level of Trek IV.