- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,425
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
Once again, we have an extraordinary film, one of the greatest in the hundred plus years of cinema's history, finally released to Blu-ray, and in a very acceptable form. In many ways, this is similar to The Misfits, less the audio problem.
When an extremely important film makes it way to home theater via the Blu-ray format, it should (now that things have settled reasonably as far as DNR and other elements that may go bump in the night) be a reason for celebration. And if discs aren't selling off the shelves, releases like Some Like it Hot could be the reason.
The quality, both visually and sonically, is very, very acceptable. But that cannot be what those great wise souls who created the format had in mind for Blu-ray. It is easily possibly for a release of films such as these to knock one's socks off.
And this doesn't.
It's just really very nice and okay.
Black levels are fine, along with shadow detail, but grain and overall resolution are lacking. Whether because of element selection, or the use of an extant master, we are not at that point where a new Blu-ray of a classic film should be.
Some Like it Hot, from M-G-M via Fox is Very Highly Recommended, albeit with technical shortcomings.
RAH
When an extremely important film makes it way to home theater via the Blu-ray format, it should (now that things have settled reasonably as far as DNR and other elements that may go bump in the night) be a reason for celebration. And if discs aren't selling off the shelves, releases like Some Like it Hot could be the reason.
The quality, both visually and sonically, is very, very acceptable. But that cannot be what those great wise souls who created the format had in mind for Blu-ray. It is easily possibly for a release of films such as these to knock one's socks off.
And this doesn't.
It's just really very nice and okay.
Black levels are fine, along with shadow detail, but grain and overall resolution are lacking. Whether because of element selection, or the use of an extant master, we are not at that point where a new Blu-ray of a classic film should be.
Some Like it Hot, from M-G-M via Fox is Very Highly Recommended, albeit with technical shortcomings.
RAH