Quentin,
Except for a few naysayers, most of the participants in this thread and the review thread loved this film. Also, personal opinion is a funny thing. Last summer, some of these same people that didn't think much of Terminator 3 were singing the praises for Spider Man which is a film that I couldn't stand to see again which is why I never purchased the dvd even though I consider myself a collector and own 2100 dvds. You know what they say "different strokes for different folks".
Crawdaddy