BrianW
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Jan 30, 1999
- Messages
- 2,563
- Real Name
- Brian
Sorry if this has been discussed before, but the search function has been disabled.
I thought U-571 was a good movie in many respects. The acting, sets, special effects, and excellent pacing all combined to do a very good job of getting me "into" this movie. But during quite a number of suspenseful moments, I was consistently taken completely out of the movie when the movie would cut to an exterior shot of the submarine.
For instance, when the sub was being driven by only one propeller (as had been revealed in the dialog), an exterior shot would show both screws spinning. In one instance, the engines were completely down, and the exterior shots again showed both screws spinning, driving the sub through the water.
Also, there was a particular exterior shot of the sub from underneath, with the sub advancing overhead. In this shots, the sub is surfaced, and you can see the water's surface and the sub's wake as the sub moves overhead. Also, the screws were always spinning in this shot. Well, they used this exterior shot numerous times when the sub was not surfaced. Indeed, they cut to this exterior shot once when the sub was supposed to have been 160 meters below the surface, with the engines completely idle.
To me, every time they cut to these shots, my Lame-O-Meter would advance another notch. They may as well have interspersed the movie with clips from episodes of Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea or even Lost in Space. It was that bad. Consequently, my suspension of disbelief was, well, suspended. And my enjoyment of an otherwise fine movie wasn't nearly what it could have been.
Am I the only one who noticed this? Or am I so ignorant of submarines that I have no idea what I'm talking about? I'll grant that my ignorance runs pretty high with such things, but I'm pretty sure that a sub at 160 meters shouldn't be leaving a wake that shimmers in the sunlight behind the sub's tail.
[Edited last by BrianW on September 04, 2001 at 08:05 PM]
I thought U-571 was a good movie in many respects. The acting, sets, special effects, and excellent pacing all combined to do a very good job of getting me "into" this movie. But during quite a number of suspenseful moments, I was consistently taken completely out of the movie when the movie would cut to an exterior shot of the submarine.
For instance, when the sub was being driven by only one propeller (as had been revealed in the dialog), an exterior shot would show both screws spinning. In one instance, the engines were completely down, and the exterior shots again showed both screws spinning, driving the sub through the water.
Also, there was a particular exterior shot of the sub from underneath, with the sub advancing overhead. In this shots, the sub is surfaced, and you can see the water's surface and the sub's wake as the sub moves overhead. Also, the screws were always spinning in this shot. Well, they used this exterior shot numerous times when the sub was not surfaced. Indeed, they cut to this exterior shot once when the sub was supposed to have been 160 meters below the surface, with the engines completely idle.
To me, every time they cut to these shots, my Lame-O-Meter would advance another notch. They may as well have interspersed the movie with clips from episodes of Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea or even Lost in Space. It was that bad. Consequently, my suspension of disbelief was, well, suspended. And my enjoyment of an otherwise fine movie wasn't nearly what it could have been.
Am I the only one who noticed this? Or am I so ignorant of submarines that I have no idea what I'm talking about? I'll grant that my ignorance runs pretty high with such things, but I'm pretty sure that a sub at 160 meters shouldn't be leaving a wake that shimmers in the sunlight behind the sub's tail.
[Edited last by BrianW on September 04, 2001 at 08:05 PM]