Search results

  1. todd s

    *** Official STAR TREK (2009) Discussion Thread

    Who is going to save the Earth when the V'ger and Whale probe come to Earth??? With the changes in the timeline...Then Enterprise might not be there to save us! :)
  2. todd s

    *** Official STAR TREK (2009) Discussion Thread

    Like I have said. I wish they would have had Kirk become first officer of the Enterprise under Pike at the end of the movie. Then have the sequel open up a few years later with Kirk taking over for Pike. It just bizarre that a guy who hasn't even graduated the academy is propelled to Captain...
  3. todd s

    *** Official STAR TREK (2009) Discussion Thread

    Another small nitpick (wouldn't be Trek without nitpicking). Why did most of the ship look sleek and modern. While engineering looked like a rundown factory from the present?? Including the shuttle bay.
  4. todd s

    *** Official STAR TREK (2009) Discussion Thread

    I guess Federation ships aren't equipped with Tom Tom or Garmin GPS systems.
  5. todd s

    *** Official STAR TREK (2009) Discussion Thread

    The one thing that kinda of irked me with Trek 2. I just find it hard to believe the Reliant crew would mistake Ceti Alpha 4 for Ceti Alpha 5. Its not like they were on the wrong block. I assume technology in the future would know the difference of planets and their locations.
  6. todd s

    *** Official STAR TREK (2009) Discussion Thread

    Or get yourself & crew killed and your ship destroyed. :D
  7. todd s

    *** Official STAR TREK (2009) Discussion Thread

    My mistake on the time machine. But, even so. Nero has 70(?) years to either fix the problem or evacuate the planet.
  8. todd s

    *** Official STAR TREK (2009) Discussion Thread

    Sorry if this has been discussed. But, was it ever explained anywhere (movie, commentary,etc) why Nero decided to destroy Vulcan? I mean if he was so devestated by the destruction of Romulus and the death of his wife & child. He had a time machine. Why not go back and save them? I really...
  9. todd s

    *** Official STAR TREK (2009) Discussion Thread

    I think the movie could have ended with Kirk being made first officer to Capt Pike on the Enterprise. Then you could have the sequel open with it being a few years later with Pike leaving and Kirk taking over.
  10. todd s

    *** Official STAR TREK (2009) Discussion Thread

    Listen people....It's just a tv show. :D
  11. todd s

    *** Official STAR TREK (2009) Discussion Thread

    Here is a pic from a scene in engineering that was cut.... ;)
  12. todd s

    *** Official STAR TREK (2009) Discussion Thread

    I thought Pine sitting with his legs crossed at the end reminded me a lot of Shatner from the original. The one big thing that still bothers me is the Kobiyashi Maru test. I so wanted Kirk to take it serious and act like he really is beating the no win scenario. Instead he acted like he...
  13. todd s

    *** Official STAR TREK (2009) Discussion Thread

    I heard a sequel has been greenlit. I wonder if its going to be a 2 or a 3 yr wait?
  14. todd s

    *** Official STAR TREK (2009) Discussion Thread

    I did enjoy the movies. And thought Urban's McCoy was spot on. But, this is a Trek thread. And what would a Trek thread be without nitpicks. So here we go... -Didn't like that Engineering looked like a manufacturing warehouse. -Had no problem with Spock & Uhura. Just surprised how much...
Top