Yes, total agreement that this new Arrow (or the Imprint version) are more definitive versions than the Twilight release. They offer more and they are an upgrade. They also address the key item that some people wanted, provide the old score on the longer cut. So, yes this is a win for any fan of...
This is what I mean about what Erickson is saying. This is pretty confused logic. He is arguing for Peckinpah's longer version but with the producer's score. In the longer version Dundee is shown, in much more detail, not to be any sort of hero, thus it makes the original score seem even more...
Agree that choice is always a good thing. I am glad that the option of having the original score play with the longer cut is now available for those that prefer it. The rest of what Mr. Erickson states seems a jumble of poorly thought out nonsense.
The entire point of creating a new score was...