Agreed on The Catered Affair. A lovely performance. But she did win the NBR (National Board Of Review) award for best supporting actress for Catered Affair. But she was truly and shockingly robbed when she wasn't nominated for Mother (1996)! She received rave reviews for her performance and...
Reynolds sole Oscar nomination was not for Tammy And The Bachelor but The Unsinkable Molly Brown. Perhaps that's what you meant to say but it reads like she was nominated for Tammy.
Would it have killed Universal to have given us the two Sandra Dee Tammy movies too in one collection? No, they're not as good but still. Definitely will be picking this one up.