Search results

  1. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Sounds like the TNG episode "Tapestry..." I always thought a TNG movie with Q made a lot of sense. Can't imagine why that was never developed.
  2. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    That's true, although it's been 13 or 14 years since Generations, and Shatner has aged, as has Nimoy. Both men look good, if you ask me, but Shatner's not going to pass for a man in his early 60s, which is how old he was when Generations was filmed.
  3. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    I wish there was some way to simply ignore the events of Generations and Nemesis, both of which are bad movies IMO. As a viewer, I'm certainly entitled to ignore those stories and focus on story progressions that make sense, but as filmmakers, Abrams or anyone else is going to have to...
  4. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Has everyone seen this item about Brent Spiner saying the reason Nemesis failed at the box office was because "the fans were done with us" ? http://www.trektoday.com/news/210107_01.shtml What a load of crap. They failed to make a good movie - which is the real reason no one came - and he...
  5. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Very true. If you were not a fan, and saw an ad for Nemesis and thought "maybe I'll see that" and then your friend who is a Star Trek fan said "I saw that, it sucked," you're not going to go. Fans will respond if you respect the source material, which Nemesis did not. Non-fans will be drawn...
  6. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Very true. It seems to be a permanent part of Paramount's Star Trek marketing. The result, at least in the Berman years, were films that sacrificed series cohesiveness to entice non-fans into the theater. And it didn't work very well, for the most part. The last two films were box office...
  7. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    A story that focuses on a TNG-era Spock and perhaps the TNG crew somehow bringing Kirk out of the Nexus could be a nice bridge to a tale of a young Kirk and Spock. Shatner is quoted as saying he and Nimoy want their roles in any new movie to be "meaningful," so I would guess that simple framing...
  8. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Actually, Nemesis opened only five DAYS before Two Towers.
  9. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Well, for one thing, in almost all of the interviews given about the movie, Rick Berman and some of the cast repeatedly proclaimed that you don't have to be a Star Trek fan to enjoy the movie. Also, in some of the newspaper ads that followed the film's release, reviews were chosen that said "you...
  10. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    While I agree that a successful movie has to appeal to those beyond the fan base, you cannot take them for granted. The problem with Nemesis is a good example -- the movie was marketed to non-fans with an almost complete disregard for longtime fans, and resulted in a film almost no one responded...
  11. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    An awful rumor has popped up: http://cinescape.com/0/editorial.asp...8&obj_id=52616 It says that Tom Cruise may appear in ST 11, perhaps in a cameo. I think this would be terrible, and if this is an indication of the type of movie it will be, it will be bad. Cameos like this are...
  12. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Small piece on Trek 11, with Greg Grunberg commenting again... http://www.scifi.com/scifiwire/index...ory=0&id=37651
  13. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    This article: http://trekweb.com/articles/2006/08/...-Trek-XI.shtml sounds fishy to me. An unnamed studio source? Even an anonymous person at the studio is not going to say what is attributed to him/her here: I guarantee you that no one involved in this project is going to say "if the...
  14. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    I always thought that's what Enterprise should have been. I would have liked to have seen a show that took place on Pike's Enterprise - just as we saw it in The Cage - and went into what was surely a groundbreaking mission. I liked what Enterprise became in its fourth season, but I still am...
  15. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Sadly, the only mention of this was a joke about it in Insurrection. The entire franchise needs to get back to the core theme of exploration, which has been missing for a very long time.
  16. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    I'd hardly say Insurrection was a "fine" film; it was very generic, borrowing plots and characters types from various Treks, and it was pretty dull overall. First Contact was a good movie, but was not the rousing adventure that the TOS movies were. Star Trek needs a return to form (DS9 may have...
  17. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Actually, it's generally accepted that TMP occured about 2 1/2 years after the first five-year mission, which would put the second five-year mission after TMP. DC Comics did a mini-series (The Untold Years? Something like that.) on the 2nd 5-year mission, which took place after TMP (and utilized...
  18. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Very true. Whereas, Galactica had but 24 episodes of a well-loved, but ultimately second tier show. Trek, meanwhile, has had some 600 episodes, 10 feature films, an animated show and 40 years of material. Re-booting that universe would be just wrong. There's still plenty to do with what's there...
  19. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Here's a new direction for the series: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hNxhr...ch=trek%20wars : )
  20. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    I wouldn't mind seeing something with Shatner and Nimoy and set in the 24th century. Neither of their characters ever really got a satisfactory resolution. A few weeks ago, we heard Stewart saying he was approached about a new movie and he was game. Now he's making comments like he's...
  21. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Another TNG film, or a DS9 movie, would be preferable, but I'd be happy with a TOS film as long as Berman and/or Braga are not involved, and as long as there is no restructuring of continuity.
  22. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Yes, and it sounds like the old Starfleet Academy idea from Harve Bennett. http://www.trektoday.com/news/210406_01.shtml I would have preferred a TNG/DS9 movie, but this is better than another Berman snooze fest. But why JJ Abrams and not Bryan Singer?
  23. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Cinescape.com has a story with comments from Rick Berman's assistant (!) saying that there will be no Trek in the short term, that nothing at all is happening with the franchise. He dismisses talk of meetings with Patrick Stewart as "casual conversation." He also said - and I can't believe this...
  24. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    It did? When? It looked like it was still standing at the end of the DS9 finale. And Data's no more deceased than Spock was, and we know it/knew it. (That's why Data's "death" was so anti-climatic.)
  25. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Bakula could be really good when they gave him something to do and when his character was written well. Check out Season 4 of Enterprise to see him at his best on the show.
  26. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    No no no. Quark had it right: "Vulcan Love Slave."
  27. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Bringing in a director like Stuart Baird wasn't a good move. He knew nothing about the series, and apparently conflicted with the actors about their characters. The series needs someone who will be faithful to the show, who respects the show and understands what made it work. The writers should...
  28. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    Here is a link that got lost in the shuffle when HTF had problems last week: http://www.trektoday.com/news/051205_01.shtml It's more about the possibility of another TNG film with Stewart (which sounds serious) and some bits about Singer's ideas for a Trek film.
  29. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    The events of Nemesis should be explained away with a few throw-away lines, such as "I began calling myself 'Data' in honor of the android whose entire memories and experience were downloaded into my positronic brain, and with the help of Geordi and the engineering crew, I've regained full use...
  30. Sam Favate

    Star Trek future movies?

    There's a report today that Patrick Stewart is saying there are meetings that are going to be held about doing another TNG movie. http://www.trektoday.com/news/011205_01.shtml Stewart said he is committed to the Royal Shakespeare Co. for 16 months, so filming would have to wait until...
Top