Search results

The finale was the best episode yet. The only time it ground to a halt was when Lauren or Scotty performed! I think this is my last Idol. I never agree with America, the show has yet to produce an artist I'd pay money to support. And with the inclusion of kids, there's something demented and...

I think this season had some of the strongest talent I've seen on the show. Which is weird since it was such a boring season. I know I watched last nights show, but I'd be hard pressed to be able to say too much about it. Thank god this snooze fest is over tonight. I wont be watching Idol again.

Paul F. Tompkins summed up last night and my feelings for the show perfectly in his masterful recap of last night:

Add me to the indifferent crowd with this show. No one is all out terrible, but no one is interesting enough to watch. Now I have to sit through the longest hour on TV to see who gets booted. It better be Jacob... he's turned the closest to unpleasant for me. They should just crown Scotty and be...

That's crazy! It's different networks isn't it? Pia has already won this thing apparently.

I see a bottom 3 of Haley, Lauren and Paul, with Haley going. She's a girl and they don't stand a chance, and the judges gave her negative feedback. Which is like an assassins bullet in this thing. I'm convinced it's the judges critical pushing of Pia that resulted in her getting the axe. If...

I disagree. Haley is a horrible singer and awkward on stage. That growly stuff sounds forced and unpleasant. This show is doomed without Pia. I mean, she held those embarrassing group numbers together with her amazing voice. Who's going to do that now? Thia Magia didn't look surprised or...

Ryan Seacrest and Brian Dunkleman! What happened to Dunkles? I think that was his name. He was the best part of season one. You could tell he though the whole thing was stupid ha ha. I actually wish I kept my tapes of season one, manly because Kelly was so insanely good on it. Not only do I...

From Paul F. Thompkins recap blog: I used to not mind Jamie Foxx as an actor, but his appearance as a mentor a season or so ago so annoyed me, I can stand the man. He doled out some truly awful advice to the singers in a such a flagrantly egomaniac fashion, only to autotune out a song...

I agree. None of them were all that great. Felt like a 5 hour show.

I had Casey (as I'm sure everyone did) as a potential winner. But the past couple weeks, not so much. It's weird, it's the Casey/Scotty conundrum.! Casery came out like a wunderkind, but is turning into a growling like demon possessed one trick pony. Scotty seemed to be a one trick pony...

I agree. I doubt Casey will win the thing, but to be bottom three this early? Then again, he's the least fashionable of the group. If you go with the general thought that only 16 year old girls and gay guys vote, on top of two weak performances and maybe he is bottom three? :P The whole hour...

I've been watching since the beginning, but new to the thread. Make me feel welcome! :P I have to say that this week, it was actually really impressive. Typically there is a performance that all out sucks, but this week, they were all pretty solid. I don;t recall ever seeing an Idol show so...