Search results

  1. Mark-W

    Roger Rabbit: VISTA review up!

    Some interesting things were brought up in the discussion that Zemekis and the at least some knew of the "naughty jokes," and how the original creator of Betty Boop traditionally used to have a few frames of her topless. This is where DVD (and LD) as mediums have probably influenced...
  2. Mark-W

    Roger Rabbit: VISTA review up!

    bird-flippage... Oh, you're making me laugh (in a good, "thank you," kind of way). Seriously, can we go back to arguing about something really important, like the blurred pubic area in Mulholland Drive? :D Mark
  3. Mark-W

    Roger Rabbit: VISTA review up!

    George- You just made the biggest grin spread accross my face! :) Back on track, I think what the "purists" would agrue is that they want the film presented and available on DVD in as close as possible to how it was original presented theatrically. If people also want "family...
  4. Mark-W

    Roger Rabbit: VISTA review up!

    Carlo- Exactly my point: the nature of the Baby Herman scene feels exactly like it was always meant to be there, if not with a single finger, then all of them extended. Honestly, the gesture doesn't work well with a fist for all the reasons you mentioned. It is the 1 or 2 frame...
  5. Mark-W

    Roger Rabbit: VISTA review up!

    Can't we all just get along? ;) Seriously though...lots of things do slip by, even in animated films. One only needs to look at the naked woman in The Rescuers for evidence of this. That shot is reminiscent of the Betty Boop and exposed Jessica shots, which leads most rational people to...
  6. Mark-W

    Roger Rabbit: VISTA review up!

    Mike- Whether we are right or wrong, it seems obvious to most that the Baby Herman finger was not something "snuck" in like the Betty Boop or exposed Jessica frames. The very nature of the Baby Herman shot makes it pretty clear that the finger could've (and probably was) intended to be...
  7. Mark-W

    Roger Rabbit: VISTA review up!

    Rain- The point is that both films have been altered to differing degrees from their original intended presentations. One has a completely different ending, footage deleted, and new material shot without the director involved. ...even if Robert Wise still doesn't think what he...
  8. Mark-W

    Roger Rabbit: VISTA review up!

    I agree with the principle behind those who argue that say they are not buying this DVD because the art has been modified in a way that seems contrary to the original creators' intentions: The Baby Herman scene was pretty clear to me in the theater, and I doubt that Zemekis didn't know...
Top