Search results

  1. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    I think they're trying to stop the "applause-o-meter" that has historically taken place during the segment, with the audience applauding loudly for the famous actors, but nothing for the lesser-known crew persons. If someone is performing, people are less likely to interrupt that performance...
  2. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    They might as well combine sound mixing and sound editing into a single award, since both categories duplicated all the nominees and the same film won both. The Oscars won by The Shape of Water are exactly the awards it won at the Critics' Choice Movie Awards.
  3. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    Or those with children just let their kids tell them who to vote for. Doubtful that the kids have watched all the nominees, but I'm sure they've all seen the latest Pixar film.
  4. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    I find this pretty surprising given the current climate in Hollywood. I figured a nominated film written and directed by a woman would have been a slam-dunk for some recognition.
  5. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    "I did it all by myself!" :laugh:
  6. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    Did anyone else find it odd that they used the theme from Austin Powers, one of the most chauvinistic/sexist characters on film in recent memory, during Viola Davis' walk out on stage for Best Supporting Actor? Seemed kind of a weird choice in the year of #metoo.
  7. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    The Fish Banging Movie Saving Lots of Privates LOL :laugh:
  8. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    The new issue of EW predicts The Shape of Water as BP.
  9. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    Get Out was released in February.
  10. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    Caught up with Dunkirk in the HT a couple nights ago. The consensus of the room was that it was a good historically-inspired war film, but there didn't seem to be anything really unique about it that would elevate it to BP status. We were also kind of disappointed that the focus of the film was...
  11. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    Yeah, I was only looking at more modern examples. Wings won at the the first ever Academy Awards, so they didn't really have any precedents/patterns yet; and there were only three nominees for Best Director against eight BP nominees when Grand Hotel won, so a lot of directors were left out that...
  12. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    Driving Miss Daisy
  13. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    The Grammys are having that sort of thing just now, with the blowback about the winners being mostly male. I haven't heard anyone explain in detail yet how the work of any of the losing artists (male or female) is superior to the winners, just that the men won because they're men and the women...
  14. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    EW put Lady Bird on the cover, but as I recall their analysis inside the magazine they're not currently predicting it to win in most categories.
  15. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    Lightest among the current DC Universe perhaps. Damning with faint praise, indeed.
  16. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    Yeah, I was kind of disappointed, too, when I saw this a while back. Decent film, but not the transcendent experience I expected based on all the box office success and wild praise of the film at time of release. It was even disappointing as a horror film, save for a few minutes at the climax...
  17. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    Exactly how I felt. I'm a huge fan of the original film and songs, and didn't care for any of the new songs. They felt out of place and seemed to lack the magic of the original songs. It's nearly impossible to duplicate the creations of the Ashman/Menken team during that time period. Mermaid...
  18. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    It's a short film, you can view on YouTube: The producers of The Space Between Us have discounted any claims of plagiarism between the two films: https://scroll.in/reel/865963/the-shape-of-water-compared-to-2015-dutch-short-netherlands-academy-shuts-down-plagiarism-murmurs
  19. Malcolm R

    Official 90th Oscar Nominations Discussion Thread

    I don't see any major surprises. They managed to freeze out (snub?) James Franco after the recent bad press, as all I see for The Disaster Artist is a screenplay nom. That film has won several awards in other recent handouts, so it's absence here is kind of notable. Also, I see the usual...
Top