Search results

  1. Holadem

    Official 2009 Oscar Discussion

    You could've fooled me, Will. -- H
  2. Holadem

    Official 2009 Oscar Discussion

    :D :D :D Not to get between the three of you, but my answer is (a resounding) "No!" as well. But it's rare to find someone openly acknowledging that they operate the other way (though plenty of people do) :D -- H
  3. Holadem

    Official 2009 Oscar Discussion

    Examples? -- H
  4. Holadem

    Official 2009 Oscar Discussion

    Or maybe we could all just accept that some people are more popular than others, even when equally dead. Not sure why that's such a bad thing. The Academy knows this, which is why they leave the biggest hitters for last, to close with high applause. Think of that last surge as applying to the...
  5. Holadem

    Official 2009 Oscar Discussion

    No, it's because of the idiot-producer who thought that the stage was more important than the screen. This applies to the entire show. I think what bugs me most about the ceremony is that if felt a lot more like (1) a celebration of the people who made the movies than (2) a celebration of the...
  6. Holadem

    Official 2009 Oscar Discussion

    Sorry but this argument is absurd on it's face I wouldn't even know where to begin. :rolleyes:I mean, as opposed to all those other Oscar noms/winners which routinely get released in the last 2 weeks of December in 2 cities? Seriously, did you really type that with a straight face? -- H
  7. Holadem

    Official 2009 Oscar Discussion

    I dunno about that. Perhaps in cyberspace, but even then I would argue that it became controversial the moment it became a phenomenon. But out in the real world where most people live, I can't say I've ever heard anyone negatively re-evaluate the thing -- nor have I witnessed the opposite, as...
  8. Holadem

    Official 2009 Oscar Discussion

    So... You claim that the film didn't get BP nom because the AA doesn't like that sort of film. At the same time, those same comic flick haters who were blind to Nolan's genius were somehow lucid enough to recognize the awesomeness of Ledger performance, but that couldn't possibly be because...
  9. Holadem

    Official 2009 Oscar Discussion

    I was astonished by the perfection of her performance (she owned the characteristic maneurism and facial expressions of a French woman in this film) till I learnt that she's been living in France since oh... forever and is essentially (and legally) uh... French. Bleh :P Seriously, good though...
  10. Holadem

    Official 2009 Oscar Discussion

    Kind of ironic, no? Others might find your resolve (of depriving yourself of a theatrical screening of a movie you obviously love just to spite some fans you've probably never met) equally "pathetic", dontchathink? :P -- H
  11. Holadem

    Official 2009 Oscar Discussion

    Ha. That's what I get for picking up on a comment out of context. What I wrote was meant to be very general and compltely unrelated to that film. Edwin's comments touched on something I've been feeling for a long time so I jumped on it without thinking of the context. I very much want to see...
  12. Holadem

    Official 2009 Oscar Discussion

    Eh. Not to derail the thread but I kinda feel the same way, though far more conflicted. On one hand, I have a passion for anything WWII. On the other, one wonders when "the West" will move on, so to speak; The trauma of that war is felt very heavily still in films and probably other artforms...
  13. Holadem

    Official 2009 Oscar Discussion

    I found nothing exceptional in the acting of both leads in RR. Frankly, it was farcical at times (see the first argument, roadside); not sure if that was intentional. -- H
  14. Holadem

    Official 2009 Oscar Discussion

    I wish TDK had gotten a BP nod as well, just to quiet down its fans (and Ledger's) which are becoming really really tireseome. Good grief. :P Seriously, a Director nod was deserved I think. But not BP IMO. Pleasantly surprised to see Jenkins from the Visitor as well. I've heard zip about...
Top