Well, the PQ on this remastered version was impressive. Very nice detail and dimensionality in this version. I compared it to the original SD DVD. The HD version is a major improvement; however, I have to say that the SD DVD still holds up well in terms of PQ as well. Color saturation on the...
Well, the original DVD of this film exhibits haloing around the ship as well. Is this the only example of haloing on the new transfer? If excessive edge enhancement was used then I would expect it to be apparent throughout the disc. If the ship is the only example then that would appear to point...
I don't get the controversy. Sometimes I have seen a similar type of haloing on original film prints during theatrical viewings. It always seems to occur at rapid transitions between areas of high contrast, especially dark areas against light backgrounds.