Mark, I totally see where you're coming from and in some instances I'm sure music can be replaced without negatively affecting overall presentation. My argument with Rory has been the position he's taking that basically says music in general doesn't make a bit of difference in this show which...
Wow, you can read the credits? Congratulations!!! That still doesn't do a damn thing to prove your point and you'll obviously never be able to admit you're wrong so just drop it. You're trying to argue something that you have no clue about and it's just going around in circles. I'm done wasting...
You just don't get it, do you? The music adds A LOT to this show the same way music is important to movies(as I mentioned above if you bothered to read what I'm trying to say). I can guarantee you that a lot of thought goes into the musical choices they use for this show and for you to discount...
WOW, I honestly don't think you could be more wrong if you tried! Would Tarantino's movies be the same without his musical choices? What about Scorcese's? The music they use in Earl is ABSOLUTELY a huge part of the show and I think most "normal" people get that.
Just read about this issue in the thread over at DVD Talk and all I can say is I'm glad I didn't buy the set. Normally music replacement wouldn't bother me that much, but the music in Earl is absolutely crucial to the show IMHO. The fact that so much good music got cut from this DVD is...