It was PJ's LOTR that got me back into Tolkien again and made Middle-earth REAL for me. I was sooo hyped up even after the first trailer of AUJ. I really thought PJ hit it out of the park. But then I saw the movie and was somewhat disappointed. I'm not a purist at all but the excessive cgi and...
I agree with a lot of what Ejanss is saying. I don't mind the extra stuff from the Appendices but the made up crap PJ came up with is horrible. And just way too much OTT in your face bad cgi. AUJ was good (not great) and DOS was a major disappointment. I'll definitely see this film but I don't...