Sergio A
Stunt Coordinator
- Joined
- May 11, 2003
- Messages
- 128
I also received the box set from Amazon.com and the glitch is there on The Wild Bunch - I also have had real problems playing the Pat Garrett DVD.
I must say, the cropping of the 2005 cut is very hard to understand, from 2.35:1 to about 2.2:1 and the decision to not really investigate the different versions through a visual comparison is quite bewildering.
Also, to my mind, the documentaries that accompany the entire set, are really distractingly shot and poorly edited - why the need to change shot every five seconds and interrupt the flow of the interviews? And why have the cameras been placed so unflatteringly when it comes to the female interviewees in particular? I ended up really wishing that Laurent Bouzerau had been handling the interviews - at least they're lit properly and the talking heads are illustrated with clips, stills and music - here all we got was jangled and disconnected editing and several slightly out of focus shots.
And they weren't even anamorphic despite being 16:9.
The set is still wonderful because the films are - PAT GARRETT though is something of a wasted opportunity - any one that has seen the Region 2 DUCK YOU SUCKER disc can compare its treatment of its varying versions in the 11-minute featurette that DVD Savant edited which is a model of its kind.
Great films in the main very well transferred - apart from THE WILD BUNCH though the extras are really quite disappointing, especially in terms of presentation and content.
Sergio
I must say, the cropping of the 2005 cut is very hard to understand, from 2.35:1 to about 2.2:1 and the decision to not really investigate the different versions through a visual comparison is quite bewildering.
Also, to my mind, the documentaries that accompany the entire set, are really distractingly shot and poorly edited - why the need to change shot every five seconds and interrupt the flow of the interviews? And why have the cameras been placed so unflatteringly when it comes to the female interviewees in particular? I ended up really wishing that Laurent Bouzerau had been handling the interviews - at least they're lit properly and the talking heads are illustrated with clips, stills and music - here all we got was jangled and disconnected editing and several slightly out of focus shots.
And they weren't even anamorphic despite being 16:9.
The set is still wonderful because the films are - PAT GARRETT though is something of a wasted opportunity - any one that has seen the Region 2 DUCK YOU SUCKER disc can compare its treatment of its varying versions in the 11-minute featurette that DVD Savant edited which is a model of its kind.
Great films in the main very well transferred - apart from THE WILD BUNCH though the extras are really quite disappointing, especially in terms of presentation and content.
Sergio