- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,424
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
Bryan Singer's Valkyrie had just enough negative press during production, that I was prepared to accept the conclusion that it was a problem film.
It isn't.
To be precise, there are elements such as actors speaking English for German roles, some with accents, others without, as well as Tom Cruise as disillusioned Nazi officer Claus von Stauffenberg...
These are elements that have been dealt with in other films in the past, in some cases successfully, and others not. As an example, reference the breakdown of actors in Kubrick's Spartacus, with American talent in the roles of slaves (with the exception of Ms. Simmons, who as I recall was from Germania) vs. English speaking Romans. Here it comes off quite nicely, as well as the transition from German to English language.
Valkyrie was shot on film in Super 35 for a 1.85:1 extraction, and that also works far better than in the past because of the digital intermediate. While I can fully understand S35 to an anamorphic final image in the photo-chemical world, I've never understood what was gained from the use of that extra tiny bit of negative real estate, only to then put the element through an optical duping process, thereby basically losing whatever may have been gained.
Here, using the additional area and then going to a DI is understandable, and makes a difference.
Something else that I loved was the overall look of the DI itself. Sharp, relatively grain free, and with an overriding look of mid-1940s three-strip Technicolor. The use of cyan as a primary for some costumes, against the red of lipstick and flags, and the overall cyan-blue push to some scenes nicely mimicked the look of some prints of the era, with cyan riding just a couple of points on the high side. This is a film where the Nazi uniforms come off beautifully, with all detail finely honed and very apparent.
Valkyrie is a quality film, as well as a quality Blu-ray. I'm certain that some will find the look problematic, far different than either Pixar animation or the first Season of CSI or True Blood. It also looks nothing like a live HD broadcast of a baseball game.
Valkyrie is a release worthy of your attention.
Recommended.
RAH
It isn't.
To be precise, there are elements such as actors speaking English for German roles, some with accents, others without, as well as Tom Cruise as disillusioned Nazi officer Claus von Stauffenberg...
These are elements that have been dealt with in other films in the past, in some cases successfully, and others not. As an example, reference the breakdown of actors in Kubrick's Spartacus, with American talent in the roles of slaves (with the exception of Ms. Simmons, who as I recall was from Germania) vs. English speaking Romans. Here it comes off quite nicely, as well as the transition from German to English language.
Valkyrie was shot on film in Super 35 for a 1.85:1 extraction, and that also works far better than in the past because of the digital intermediate. While I can fully understand S35 to an anamorphic final image in the photo-chemical world, I've never understood what was gained from the use of that extra tiny bit of negative real estate, only to then put the element through an optical duping process, thereby basically losing whatever may have been gained.
Here, using the additional area and then going to a DI is understandable, and makes a difference.
Something else that I loved was the overall look of the DI itself. Sharp, relatively grain free, and with an overriding look of mid-1940s three-strip Technicolor. The use of cyan as a primary for some costumes, against the red of lipstick and flags, and the overall cyan-blue push to some scenes nicely mimicked the look of some prints of the era, with cyan riding just a couple of points on the high side. This is a film where the Nazi uniforms come off beautifully, with all detail finely honed and very apparent.
Valkyrie is a quality film, as well as a quality Blu-ray. I'm certain that some will find the look problematic, far different than either Pixar animation or the first Season of CSI or True Blood. It also looks nothing like a live HD broadcast of a baseball game.
Valkyrie is a release worthy of your attention.
Recommended.
RAH