Search results

George Huff - Not his best, but he is growing on me. Jennifer - Still don't like her and her voice is nowhere near as good as she thinks it is. JPL - The hobbit must go. Diana DeGarmo - The Stepford child, hated her nasally rendition. Fantasia - NAILED IT. Don't mind the raspy voice...

That was funny. When I discuss the show with my friend, we refer to Diana DeGarmo as Jon-Benet.:D

I actually think that, as a group, these 12 are better than the 2 first seasons. That said, there is no Clay, Reuben or Kelly here. My picks: VERY VERY GOOD: Jasmine: best of the night, hell of a singer, may be too young though. LaToya: You could tell she sings professionally, had more...

It's amazing that so many people watching the same show can have so many different opinions.... I thought: 1) Diana gave the best performance. 2) Fantasia was the most distinctive and had the best song choice. 3) Erksine was "fun" 4) Katie was just OK 5) Everyone else was far behind...

While I agree that scooter girl had a great voice, everything else about her screamed broadway at me. I could easily see her on stage in any manner of muscial comedy but not really as a pop star.

I can't believe no one's mentioned the little person yet. I have no idea how this is going to unfold. She absolutely has the pipes, in fact, vocally, I'd put her in the top 10 people they've shown so far. But realistically, how far is she going to go, and won't everything be tainted by the...