Seps are very noticeably soft. Y layer has fade + chem damage. M layer has chemical damage. C seems decent.
Printer functions are built into the masters, which is another problem.
In MGM-speak, “pristine.
I’m merely noting the technological differences. The other attribute is the communal sharing of the experience.
Don’t get me wrong.
Home Theaters of a certain quality can absolutely mimic the experience of a theater, and provide a very pleasant mechanism for viewing a film.
But it cannot...
Possibly it’s a covid thing, and people have been sequestered too long.
The overriding concept of Film restoration is to bring a motion picture back to theaters on huge screens, with equally intimidating sound systems.
It has now been distilled to the lowest common denominator, wherein someone...
Not a major issue, but to an archivist, when something is re-cut, it is no longer original.
for the record, the roadshow can still be reconstructed. It just won’t be pretty.
Ultimately, it’s an educational exercise, for as I know the film well, I consider the shorter version to be better.
And...
The gentleman who receives his freedom from Jim Bowie, was played by Jester Hairston, a wonderful actor worth researching.
Educated at Tufts and Julliard, with a career in music, he worked toward preserving the Negro spiritual.
Somewhere in the mess that is the MGM inventory, should be a...
What has been neglected to be mentioned in this wonderful piece, is that after the 70mm print, which with the cooperation of those who discovered it Toronto, as well as Mr. May, who arranged for the print to rest at the AMPAS cold vault, was transferred...
It was cut into 800 foot sections...
The print used for transfer was damaged during the job. Certain footage was replaced with re-used shots. Also, and more important, the scanner was unable to achieve anywhere near full frame, so that major real estate is lost. Just an unfortunate situation all around. The Todd credit should have...
Most likely the laser transfer. 480i within a box. And definitely NOT the uncut roadshow version. Something either is or is not. This is not, regardless of how it might be promoted.
The site seems to say that they’re releasing both the uncut as well as the cut. 2 BDs and a DVD.
MGM may have harvested an image from their pristine OCN, and then cropped the top and bottom to get to 2.35.
Per public comments from MGM, the original 65mm elements are pristine. This means that a restoration is not necessary.
They should be able to easily produce a new 4k.