3 Stars

Hello all. I am a huge fan of this movie, first of all because I worked at a Cinerama theatre in Wichita, Kansas in 1962 and 1963 and was there for the premieres of both HTWWW and WWOTBG; and secondly, because this movie to me is highly entertaining, well-acted and directed and is, as they say, “one for the ages.” Anyway, does anyone know that there is a group of supporters of this movie called “Friends of the Brothers Grimm?” Some time back they got a petition together, which as far as I know is still on line, getting signatures so that eventually the petition can be submitted to Warner Bros., requesting that “Grimm” be restored (a la HTWWW) and released on BluRay. I am hoping that perhaps David Strohmaier, Cinerama restoration guru, may already be working on this project, since WWOTBG is the only remaining Cinerama film which has not yet been restored. Also, my limited research has revealed that supposedly the only remaining print of this film is owned by a man in Australia; and a 65mm interpositive exists which contains all 3 panels somewhere, plus the negatives, according to some sources, are available and useable! If you haven’t seen some of Mr. Strohmaier’s Cinerama restorations on BluRay, check them out. He has worked many miracles in restoring these great Cinerama productions. So let’s all keep talking about this and keep our fingers crossed that “The Wonderful World of the Brothers Grimm” will truly live again!

Published by

Kevin Collins

administrator

Matt Hough

Director
Reviewer
Joined
Apr 24, 2006
Messages
21,929
Location
Charlotte, NC
Real Name
Matt Hough
The film certainly has its fans on this forum (including me despite some of its lapses). I signed that petition it seems ages ago. Since Warners controls this movie and it has been made clear to us on many occasions that preparing it for Blu-ray release would be a time consuming and ruinously expensive process, many of us have given up hope of actually seeing it come to BD. Warners never went any farther than laserdisc with it not even granting it a DVD signifying possibly that it was not a big seller for them. (Contrarily, How the West Was Won kept getting released repeatedly from tape to laserdisc to DVD and finally Blu-ray, every time with a transfer superior to what had gone before.)

So, keeping my fingers crossed that it might one day come to us even if only in streaming form, but not really expecting anything other than what I've already got (the laserdisc).
 

Ed Lachmann

Screenwriter
Joined
Mar 17, 2011
Messages
1,282
Real Name
Edmund Lachmann
Count me in for this title. Saw it back in '63 as a kid and LOVED it. I still have the gorgeous yellow hardcover program from that screening. The gentle touch of George Pal is always enchanting and something we could use a lot more of in today's world. So hope we will see it in HD someday soon.
 

haineshisway

Cinematographer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Oct 26, 2011
Messages
4,645
Location
Los Angeles
Real Name
Bruce
Warners is not going to give this to Dave - why would anyone think such a thing? And yes, one panel (I forget which) is water damaged - who knows how severely, but if it's severe there's probably no way to save it. Then again, Warners has pulled rabbits out of hats before.
 

OliverK

Cinematographer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Feb 1, 2000
Messages
4,373
Warners is not going to give this to Dave - why would anyone think such a thing? And yes, one panel (I forget which) is water damaged - who knows how severely, but if it's severe there's probably no way to save it. Then again, Warners has pulled rabbits out of hats before.
As you know most of us think that it might be better to have Grimm in decent HD quality so you would probably call it wishful thinking that Warner would let somebody else handle Grimm.

If at some point they had even done a 2k scan of each panel they could give those files away and let somebody have a go with it - all assets would stay in house and people could finally see a version of the movie with decent resolution, even with the water damage.

Or we can look at it positively and say that Warner is probably hoping for automated techniques to become available that will help with dealing with the panel with the water damage.

With that being said I would love to finally be able to watch this one but I refuse to watch it in LD or DVD quality.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darby67

Thomas T

Cinematographer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Sep 30, 2001
Messages
4,562
Maybe if we create a go fund me page and each contribute $10,000 apiece towards that million plus Grimm restoration, it would help. After all, fans of Wonderful World Of The Brothers Grimm would put money where their mouth is, wouldn't we. ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darby67

OliverK

Cinematographer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Feb 1, 2000
Messages
4,373
Maybe if we create a go fund me page and each contribute $10,000 apiece towards that million plus Grimm restoration, it would help. After all, fans of Wonderful World Of The Brothers Grimm would put money where their mouth is, wouldn't we. ;)
If that meant releasing Grimm in another way than the Warner way it might be possible. With the Warner price tag unfortunately not.

But most of us know that already and then from time to time threads like this one pop up and we go over all of it again :)
 

cinemiracle

Screenwriter
Joined
May 1, 2015
Messages
1,135
Real Name
Peter
Hello all. I am a huge fan of this movie, first of all because I worked at a Cinerama theatre in Wichita, Kansas in 1962 and 1963 and was there for the premieres of both HTWWW and WWOTBG; and secondly, because this movie to me is highly entertaining, well-acted and directed and is, as they say, "one for the ages." Anyway, does anyone know that there is a group of supporters of this movie called "Friends of the Brothers Grimm?" Some time back they got a petition together, which as far as I know is still on line, getting signatures so that eventually the petition can be submitted to Warner Bros., requesting that "Grimm" be restored (a la HTWWW) and released on BluRay. I am hoping that perhaps David Strohmaier, Cinerama restoration guru, may already be working on this project, since WWOTBG is the only remaining Cinerama film which has not yet been restored. Also, my limited research has revealed that supposedly the only remaining print of this film is owned by a man in Australia; and a 65mm interpositive exists which contains all 3 panels somewhere, plus the negatives, according to some sources, are available and useable! If you haven't seen some of Mr. Strohmaier's Cinerama restorations on BluRay, check them out. He has worked many miracles in restoring these great Cinerama productions. So let's all keep talking about this and keep our fingers crossed that "The Wonderful World of the Brothers Grimm" will truly live again!
Well acted? The two male leads were woeful.
 

DP 70

Screenwriter
Joined
Oct 16, 2011
Messages
1,046
Real Name
Derek
I have seen the only 3 panel print of this a few times at Bradford, and the Centre Panel has one of the best focus i have ever seen in a cinema.
This would look fantastic on 4K UHD but shame about the state of the original neg.
 

OliverK

Cinematographer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Feb 1, 2000
Messages
4,373
I think WB also has an Ultra Panavision print, but I don't know what the condition is.
If the 70mm print that I saw of HTWWW is anything to go by it would not matter that much as it would be very soft and worse than a decent 35mm print. It seems that cinerama never really found a way to bring its process to a single film strip in a quality that would compare favorably to even standard 35mm which can also be seen when looking at the first This is Cinerama release on Blu-ray that looked very disappointing.

That being said I might still be tempted to buy if a Blu-ray was created from that print as it should still look better than the laserdisc version. Or maybe I really need to go to Bradford once to see the real thing...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darby67

MarkantonyII

Agent
Joined
Dec 17, 2016
Messages
39
Real Name
Mark
Major physical differences between the two film.

How is a basically unfaded set of negatives, while Grimm is incomplete and water damaged.

I’ve not budgeted, but think 1.5 - 1.8 million.
Mr Harris, do you know if the water damage assertion is definitive or is it just one of those things that's been banded about for years and no-one has properly examined it - was it stored independently or just unlucky?
 

haineshisway

Cinematographer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Oct 26, 2011
Messages
4,645
Location
Los Angeles
Real Name
Bruce
Mr Harris, do you know if the water damage assertion is definitive or is it just one of those things that's been banded about for years and no-one has properly examined it - was it stored independently or just unlucky?
I'm not Mr. Harris, but two people here have told you one of the panels is water damaged - we both know whereof we speak. We don't bandy about things :)
 

MarkantonyII

Agent
Joined
Dec 17, 2016
Messages
39
Real Name
Mark
I'm not Mr. Harris, but two people here have told you one of the panels is water damaged - we both know whereof we speak. We don't bandy about things :)
Very true, I wasn't casting aspersions, but you did say "...who knows how severely..." which implies if not states that very little examination has taken place, and / or the results of which are not widely known, which leaves the answer wide open to interpretation.

M
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darby67

Strohmaier

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Sep 16, 2012
Messages
162
Real Name
David Strohmaier
The Grim truth about “Brothers Grimm”

The ownership and copyright of both dramatic Cinerama titles “HTWWW” and “Brothers Grimm” is shared 50-50 between (formally MGM) now Warner Bros. and Cinerama Inc. As part of the major Cinerama revival efforts done starting in 2000 I have had first hand knowledge of the condition of all the Cinerama elements which include “Brothers Grimm” even though it has been vaulted at Warners. At that time I represented the 50% owner of the title, Gunther Jung, also of Cinerama Inc. and John Sittig, Director of Cinerama Inc. and myself along with Warner’s Dick May, now retired, did several photo chemical tests at Crest labs in 2002 of the water damaged sections and the availability and condition of the o-neg elements. I had received a copy thru Dick of the 1995 o-negative inspection reports where multiple problems such as this damage was listed. A little less than half of the rolls had notations of moderate to severe water damage due to a flood in one of the vaults years earlier. We did print up one small 300 foot section of a water damaged panel and found that the damage was mostly on the left edge, but other rolls could be on different sides. We also found there were a few rolls of missing o-negatives, but we never got around to checking on the YCM separation masters to see if they were complete or not. We had found earlier that the Cinerama travelogues did not all have complete sep. masters so perhaps Grimm has them complete?

Assuming the sep masters are complete then yes a restoration could be accomplished on “Grimm” however just imagine the expense of 9 B&W film frame elements (Y-C-M x3) to create 1 Cinerama 3-panel frame on the screen. Then if there is any shrinkage problems of the Y-C-M elements (as in misregistration) you would have one huge budget problem or the most expensive restoration/scanning job ever to end up with digital elements such as we have done with the travelogues.

On our Cinerama travelogue restorations we were fortunate to have the Library of Congress 3-panel deposit Eastmancolor faded prints available to scan our missing sections and then rebuild back the color, however as I understand it from my pals at LOC there is no 3-panel 6-perf IB prints of “Grimm” on deposit which could possibly fill in any missing and damaged areas. They only have the 35mm scope general release version.

Is “Brothers Grimm” digitally restorable? I would say the answer is possibly but a very hesitant yes. However it should be understood that it might not look as pristine as “HTWWW”. FYI -the o-negs on “HTWWW” were in excellent condition when we started printing up the answer print at Crest labs back in 2001. Warner Brother’s digital transfer work was started in 2006 from this same element for the blue ray release in the fall of 2008. This neg did not need very much clean up or digital restoration work. Blending the 3-panels back together again was a major part of that work.

The reason I say possibly yes is that after our “Windjammer” Cinemiracle experience - dealing with such severe damage, shrinkage, fading, dirt, chemical blotches, warpage, missing panels vinegar syndrome and even entire rolls missing, nothing can ever scare me again. “Windjammer” turned out better than we could ever have imagined.

In a nutshell -this is how I would approach “Grimm” without a 1.5+ mil budget: For starters carefully scan the Bradford UK IB tech 3-panel Cinerama 6 perf. print as well as some IB Tech 6 perf. elements we have recently located in Sweden. Then add in what is still usable of the o-negs favoring them where possible. In areas that simply cannot be saved then go from the YCM seps. Perhaps as a last resort, for troubled areas, use the 65mm IP, an optical created from the 3-panels at Metrocolor labs in the 1960s, this apparently has no cropping on the sides. If that element is used then attempt some better panel blending tricks on the optical printer join areas.

Then a very slow and difficult 3-panel blending operation, clean up, dust busting and flicker removal. Finally the blending (color and density etc.) of the various composite 3-panel source materials to facilitate in minimizing the “checkerboard” look of these different elements. Thus make it as close as possible to appear like it’s all from one basic source. A challenge for sure!