A classic that never grows stale 4.5 Stars

A genuine holiday classic, Miracle on 34th Street still works its magical story of heart and hope, faith and trust seven decades after its original release.

Miracle on 34th Street (1947)
Released: 02 Oct 1947
Rated: APPROVED
Runtime: 96 min
Director: George Seaton
Genre: Comedy, Drama, Family
Cast: Maureen O'Hara, John Payne, Edmund Gwenn, Gene Lockhart
Writer(s): George Seaton (written for the screen by), Valentine Davies (story)
Plot: When a nice old man who claims to be Santa Claus is institutionalized as insane, a young lawyer decides to defend him by arguing in court that he is the real thing.
IMDB rating: 7.9
MetaScore: N/A

Disc Information
Studio: Fox
Distributed By: N/A
Video Resolution: 1080P/AVC
Aspect Ratio: 1.37:1
Audio: English 2.0 DD, English 5.1 DTS-HDMA, Spanish 2.0 DD, French 2.0 DD
Subtitles: English SDH, Spanish
Rating: Not Rated
Run Time: 1 Hr. 36 Min.
Package Includes: Blu-ray, Digital Copy
Case Type: keep case in a slipcase
Disc Type: BD50 (dual layer)
Region: A
Release Date: 10/10/2017
MSRP: $19.99

The Production: 4.5/5

There are a handful of holiday film perennials that start to make themselves known around this time of year: It’s a Wonderful Life, several different incarnations of Dickens’ A Christmas Carol, and the magnificent 1947 charmer Miracle on 34th Street. If it’s less grandiose than It’s a Wonderful Life or less fanciful than A Christmas Carol, Miracle on 34th Street seems much more grounded in reality and thus represents an appealing alternative to such otherwise fanciful holiday fare. So, do I believe in Santa Claus? After years of watching Miracle on 34th Street, I’m still not quite sure. The movie is so beautifully put together that it’s hard not to. This 70th Anniversary Edition of the movie is its second Blu-ray release and is the identical disc from eight years ago. Only, a digital copy has been added to the package.

Doris Walker (Maureen O’Hara) is a no-nonsense holiday organizer for Macy’s Department Store in New York City. Divorced with a six-year old daughter Susan (Natalie Wood), Doris keeps a tight rein on young Susan’s flights of fancy, but her strict mistrust of anything fanciful gets a solid shakedown when Kris Kringle (Edmund Gwenn) begins working as the department store Santa Claus at Macy’s. He insists he’s actually Santa Claus and makes it his business to spread holiday cheer not only to Doris and Susan but throughout the store and especially to Fred Gailey (John Payne), Doris’ apartment house neighbor who’d love to get closer to Doris and Susan but disagrees with Doris’ overly rigid child-rearing tendencies. Trouble ensues when department store psychologist Granville Sawyer (Porter Hall) takes an instant dislike to the agreeable Kris Kringle and looks for ways to get him committed as insane.

Stretching from Thanksgiving to Christmas, George Seaton’s Oscar-winning screenplay (based on the Oscar-winning original story by Valentine Davies) has more than the requisite amount of whimsy, humor, warmth, and emotional connection, and individual sequences in the film like Santa’s emotionally rich encounter with a lonely Dutch girl, Kris’ teaching Susan how to mimic a monkey, the two Kris/Sawyer smackdowns, and the climactic trial scenes in which a real miracle is desperately needed to save the day leaving the audience rather nervous as to the outcome still resonate joyously seventy years after the film’s first release. True, Seaton’s direction is nothing special. It’s competent and comfortable in that studio-bound tradition of the period in which the movie was produced (Gwenn really did play Santa in the 1946 Macy’s Parade; those are not staged backlot shots but were photographed in New York City during some actual location photography), but that overall lack of dazzle in most of the interior scenes is also part of secret to the movie’s charm. Its effect on the viewer’s persona is earned honestly through the clever lines, the engaging characters, and the special camaraderie evinced by the members of the cast who carry out their roles with the utmost sincerity and accuracy.

Neither Maureen O’Hara nor John Payne were ever any better than they are in the film with these simple but wonderfully genuine portrayals. Natalie Wood’s gradual resurrection into the world of childhood from the dour, serious-minded child-adult she is when we first see her is one of the screen’s most delightful juvenile performances (why she wasn’t honored with a juvenile Oscar that year is an unfathomable mystery). Edmund Gwenn’s Oscar-winning Santa is a delight, and if he isn’t really Santa Claus, the real thing should be modeled on this terrific copy. Porter Hall gets to be the movie’s risible villain, and he’s entirely worthy of the raspberries. Gene Lockhart shifts around most uncomfortably as the judge who takes on the case against Santa Claus while farther down the cast list are memorable early appearances by Thelma Ritter and Jack Albertson, both simply delectable playing stock characters which they’d develop with even more surety in the years to come.

Video: 4.5/5

3D Rating: NA

The film’s 1.37:1 theatrical aspect ratio is delivered in a 1080p transfer using the AVC codec. Though an occasional shot or two seem overly dark and a bit lackluster, most of the film is sharp and beautifully detailed with a very solid grayscale rendering that produces impressive high definition images. The grain structure is retained and offers a very film-like image while the transfer’s sharpness makes the occasional use of rear projection screens obvious and typically period. Occasional inconsistencies in contrast don’t weigh down the visual presentation. The film has been divided into 24 chapters.

Audio: 4/5

The DTS-HD Master Audio repurposed 5.1 sound mix (obviously taken from stereo sound stems when the music was recorded) basically allows the delightful Cyril J. Mockridge music score to be opened up into the surround channels where it sounds wonderfully recorded and is pretty demonstrative without overpowering the dialog which is rooted to the center channel. In the quietest moments, you might catch a tiny bit of low level hiss, but it’s never objectionable. However, the surrounds are virtually silent for much of the movie, and there really isn’t much on the low end of the mix. The lossy Dolby Digital 2.0 mono mix (very low bitrate 192 kbps) is available for those who wish a mono track to recreate the original theatrical experience.

Special Features: 3.5/5

Audio Commentary: Maureen O’Hara contributes a lovely commentary, a sweet reminiscence about coming to America and how she came to make the film. There are many silent spots, but fans of the film will appreciate this commentary carried over from the film’s DVD release.

Hollywood Backstory: Miracle on 34th Street (22:06, SD): the usual excellent summation/behind-the-scenes story on the making of the film. Among the participants in telling the story are film historian Rudy Belhmer, original star Maureen O’Hara plus other bit actors from the film and Natalie Wood’s sister Lana.

Fox Movietone: Hollywood Spotlight (1:46, SD): brief newsreel footage reporting on Fox’s big night of wins of the major 1947 Oscars with the triumphant Gentleman’s Agreement and Miracle on 34th Street each winning three Oscars apiece.

Promotional Short (5:08, SD): takes a unique approach to selling the movie without any mention of its holiday theme. (The film was a summer release but was so popular it ran through the holiday season.) Rex Harrison and Anne Baxter make quick appearances, and that looks like Gene Nelson in the background as a studio executive.

Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade: Floating in History (15:32, SD): goes into some detail on the arrangements made for Fox to shoot the 1946 Macy’s Parade for use in the movie using Maureen O’Hara and Edmund Gwenn in the actual parade being covered by dozens of cameras.

Art Gallery: a brief step-through poster gallery of black and white posters and one sheets for advertising the movie.

Digital Copy: code sheet enclosed in the case.

Overall: 4.5/5

A genuine holiday classic, Miracle on 34th Street still works its magical story of heart and hope, faith and trust seven decades after its original release. For those who don’t already have this film on Blu-ray or need a digital copy to complete their collections, highly recommended!

Published by

Matt Hough

editor,member

B-ROLL

Cinematographer
Joined
May 26, 2016
Messages
2,569
Reaction score
2,326
Points
4,110
Real Name
Bryan
I'm 99% sure this is a repackaging of the 2009 Blu-ray - can anyone confirm 100%?
This 70th Anniversary Edition of the movie is its second Blu-ray release and is the identical disc from eight years ago. Only, a digital copy has been added to the package.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Osato

LeoA

Cinematographer
Joined
Dec 31, 2008
Messages
2,957
Reaction score
1,523
Points
4,110
Location
North Country
Real Name
Leo
Didn't I read on this forum that this came with a DVD bonus disc with the Teresa Wright tv movie adaptation on it? Did that end up not being the case?

Edit: Nevermind, I understand now what the specifications meant by "DVD ONLY" for this bonus feature.

I had misinterpreted that to mean that it was included here on a second disc as an extra, presumably on DVD rather than Blu-Ray because of limitations with the source that would've made a BD overkill. But they're actually saying that it's only included with the DVD version of the 70th Anniversary Edition.

Too bad they couldn't of snuck it in as a SD extra on the Blu-Ray itself. Would be 480i rather than 480p I believe, but for a kinescope, I doubt that's too much of a drawback.
 
Last edited:

Matt Hough

Director
Reviewer
Joined
Apr 24, 2006
Messages
21,771
Reaction score
11,355
Points
9,110
Location
Charlotte, NC
Real Name
Matt Hough
Didn't I read on this forum that this came with a DVD bonus disc with the Teresa Wright tv movie adaptation on it? Did that end up not being the case?

Edit: Nevermind, I understand now what the specifications meant by "DVD ONLY" for this bonus feature.

I had misinterpreted that to mean that it was included here on a second disc as an extra, presumably on DVD rather than Blu-Ray because of limitations with the source that would've made a BD overkill. But they're actually saying that it's only included with the DVD version of the 70th Anniversary Edition.

Too bad they couldn't of snuck it in as a SD extra on the Blu-Ray itself. Would be 480i rather than 480p I believe, but for a kinescope, I doubt that's too much of a drawback.
I made the same mistaken assumption when I got the review copy and opened it. I expected a DVD to be sitting behind the digital code sheet, and it wasn't. Reading the back cover of the keep case revealed there was only one disc in the case.

I agree. For a 70th anniversary celebration release, Fox could and should have gone to a little more trouble to celebrate such a classic. I think this was a missed opportunity.
 

BobO'Link

Lead Actor
Joined
May 3, 2008
Messages
6,525
Reaction score
7,946
Points
9,110
Location
Mid-South
Real Name
Howie
Yeah, I don't get why they didn't include the DVD in the BR package considering it's an "Anniversary" release. Oh well... I don't own a copy of the previous BR, this is less expensive, I love the film, and my son will have a digital copy. I'll just put my old DVD in the case with this one (or sub a 2 disc case if needed) for the few extras it has this doesn't. It's still a win for me! :D
 

Rick Thompson

Screenwriter
Joined
Jul 1, 2008
Messages
1,635
Reaction score
990
Points
1,610
Glad I didn't order this. Not at all interested in the old kinescope, ditto the digital copy.
 
Last edited:

bujaki

Producer
Joined
Jan 1, 2012
Messages
4,385
Reaction score
3,746
Points
4,110
Age
70
Location
Richardson, TX
Real Name
Jose Ortiz-Marrero
Is it a kinescope? What I saw in the Fox Movie Channel was filmed in 35mm and looked splendid.
 

Nick*Z

Screenwriter
Joined
Apr 30, 2003
Messages
1,150
Reaction score
1,689
Points
1,610
Age
49
Location
Canada
Website
nixpixdvdmoviereviewsandmore.blogspot.ca
Real Name
NICK
The original Blu of Miracle is flawed - too dark, and a lot of edge effects during the court room scenes. Fox not going back to the drawing board to correct these anomalies and rid us of a digitally harsh transfer is a HUGE disappointment. Will be canceling my Amazon order on this one. Thanks Matt.
 

Gary16

Screenwriter
Joined
Oct 19, 2006
Messages
1,221
Reaction score
1,792
Points
1,610
Real Name
Gary
The other version is not a kinescope. Shot on 35mm for the 20th Century Fox anthology series that aired in the 50s.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LeoA

LeoA

Cinematographer
Joined
Dec 31, 2008
Messages
2,957
Reaction score
1,523
Points
4,110
Location
North Country
Real Name
Leo
The other version is not a kinescope. Shot on 35mm for the 20th Century Fox anthology series that aired in the 50s.
Thanks

I read somewhere that it was a kinescope. Sorry for the spreading incorrect information.
 

Colin Jacobson

Lead Actor
Joined
Apr 19, 2000
Messages
9,764
Reaction score
3,498
Points
9,110
It's a banner week for "anniversary editions that just offer repackagings", since the 30th Anniversary "Planes, Trains and Automobiles" just reboxes the old one, too! :rolleyes:
 

Robert Crawford

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Dec 9, 1998
Messages
47,612
Reaction score
23,710
Points
9,110
Location
Michigan
Real Name
Robert
It's a banner week for "anniversary editions that just offer repackagings", since the 30th Anniversary "Planes, Trains and Automobiles" just reboxes the old one, too! :rolleyes:
Not just Anniversary releases as Paramount, Universal and some other studios are re-releasing a bunch of titles during this last four months of 2017.
 

Colin Jacobson

Lead Actor
Joined
Apr 19, 2000
Messages
9,764
Reaction score
3,498
Points
9,110
Not just Anniversary releases as Paramount, Universal and some other studios are re-releasing a bunch of titles during this last four months of 2017.
The "Planes, Trains..." one is odd because it's the only one Paramount promoted to reviewers.

I debated whether to even call it a "30th Anniversary Edition" since it's exactly the same product in exactly the same package with just a sticker that mentions the 30th anniversary.

But if I'm gonna review it, I gotta specify the difference somehow, so I called it a "30th Anniversary Edition"!
 

Rick Thompson

Screenwriter
Joined
Jul 1, 2008
Messages
1,635
Reaction score
990
Points
1,610
I have to disagree with the reviewer on George Seaton's direction ("Seaton’s direction is nothing special. It’s competent and comfortable in that studio-bound tradition of the period. . .") of Miracle. It's exactly what the film required. Part of good direction is knowing when to be simply simple. Seaton knew that with this story and this cast, he had something special, and he served it best by staying out of the way and letting what he had work its magic. Any kind of flashy direction would hurt the film. Seaton got it just right.