Charlie O.
Supporting Actor
- Joined
- May 13, 2003
- Messages
- 509
Can some explain to me what the point of window boxing is and how it preserves an aspect ratio?
pillarboxingLearn something new every day.
Look at the first short on Disney Treasures, Mickey Mouse in B&W, for example.Ha, funny that you mentioned that because viewing Steamboat Willy is what made me start this thread. I compared the window boxed DVD to an old 4:3 verison I had on tape and didn't any difference other then the DVD had rounded corners.
Galaxy Quest had three ARs for the theatrical presentation.
The "vintage" clip was presented 1.33:1.
All scenes on Earth were presented 1.85:1.
The rest of the film was 2.35:1.
For DVD, it was decided to make it easier and just keep the 1.33:1 AR for the "vintage" clip and the rest of the film would be 2.35:1.Thank you. I saw this at cinema, and thought that they had used 3 ARs, and was surprised to only find two on the DVD.
Does anyone know how they did this? The headroom on the DVD looks fine, so I suspect they just opened it up at the sides.
Does anyone know how they did this? The headroom on the DVD looks fine, so I suspect they just opened it up at the sides.Theatrical prints were 2.39:1 scope. The other narrow ARs were achieved by having black bars on the side of the image on the film prints themselves. The 1.85:1 were segments were most likely filmed as 2.39:1 with the intention of adding black bars on the theatrical prints, so the DVD just removes the black bars, showing the entire exposed film area for that portion.
DJ
I think it's a stupid idea really. I have a 10-year old Sony which I've calibrated to virtually eliminate overscan, and when I view any DVDs on my PC I obviously do not lose anything to overscan either.The vast majority of people have TVs that do overscan, some more severely than others. Most people don't know how to adjust the overscan or flat-out can't adjust the overscan. In short, you are in a very, very small percentile.
Whenever I make DVDs, I always reduce the image size by 10% during the MPEG creation process to compensate for the overscanning on all of my TVs, including my 55" Mitsu 16:9.
Just because you don't need it for your particular TV doesn't make it a stupid idea.