David Ely
Supporting Actor
- Joined
- Sep 1, 1998
- Messages
- 753
I can't believe I only heard about this now.
For some reason, someone came up with the brilliant idea that they should remake a film that's only 4 years old! Insomnia is one of my favorite films. I couldn't count the number of times I've watched my Criterion DVD. The original film is perfect. If they want more people to see it, they should release it as-is in the theater.
Remakes rarely work as well as the original film. I can't even imagine anyone other than the absolutely brilliant Stellan Skarsgård in the lead role. Al Pacino? Sorry, just can't see it.
Obviously I can't make any specific comments without seeing any actual footage from the movie. But I would like to suggest to the members of this forum that if you haven't seen the original, go checkout the DVD.
For some reason, someone came up with the brilliant idea that they should remake a film that's only 4 years old! Insomnia is one of my favorite films. I couldn't count the number of times I've watched my Criterion DVD. The original film is perfect. If they want more people to see it, they should release it as-is in the theater.
Remakes rarely work as well as the original film. I can't even imagine anyone other than the absolutely brilliant Stellan Skarsgård in the lead role. Al Pacino? Sorry, just can't see it.
Obviously I can't make any specific comments without seeing any actual footage from the movie. But I would like to suggest to the members of this forum that if you haven't seen the original, go checkout the DVD.