Joe Lugoff
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Feb 4, 2005
- Messages
- 2,238
- Real Name
- Joe
I can add "Leave It to Beaver" with 234 episodes and "Father Knows Best" with 203.
249 episodes out of 327 is not bad.JohnMor said:The Andy Griffith Show clocks in at 249 eps on dvd.
Well, I guess the distinction being made there was that in the case of Mayberry and Archie Bunker's Place (and the unreleased Sanford Arms), those were direct replacements (continuing in place of the original, or a re-tooled show with the intention of keeping the franchise going) for the original shows rather than separate spin-offs (they may have even inherited the original shows' day/timeslots), whereas stuff like Rhoda, The Jeffersons, Maude, etc. are more properly spinoffs than direct replacements of their parent shows. I agree, most people count them as different shows, but it would also be unfair to place them in the same category as shows like Maude, Rhoda, Gloria, Lou Grant, etc. They're a slightly different category.Joe Lugoff said:Mr. Mooney, you're the only person I know who counts MAYBERRY R.F.D. as part of THE ANDY GRIFFITH SHOW. It's a separate series, a spinoff. If you do that, you have to count ARCHIE BUNKER'S PLACE, THE JEFFERSONS and MAUDE as part of ALL IN THE FAMILY ... or RHODA, PHYLLIS and LOU GRANT as part of THE MARY TYLER MOORE SHOW. It seems kind of goofy to consider something to be THE ANDY GRIFFITH SHOW when Andy Griffith isn't in it.
Originally Posted by Theodore J. Mooney
Well, I guess the distinction being made there was that in the case of Mayberry and Archie Bunker's Place (and the unreleased Sanford Arms), those were direct replacements (continuing in place of the original, or a re-tooled show with the intention of keeping the franchise going) for the original shows rather than separate spin-offs (they may have even inherited the original shows' day/timeslots), whereas stuff like Rhoda, The Jeffersons, Maude, etc. are more properly spinoffs than direct replacements of their parent shows.
I agree, most people count them as different shows, but it would also be unfair to place them in the same category as shows like Maude, Rhoda, Gloria, Lou Grant, etc. They're a slightly different category.
Well, yes, of course they're separate projects. I wasn't arguing otherwise (and assumed that was obvious), just that such "sequel" shows are in a somewhat different category than the traditional spin-off and shouldn't just be lumped together with them. As someone earlier up the thread mentioned, Dark Shadows isn't likely to be beaten in this particular 'contest', no matter how a person decides to add up things.JohnMor said:
And before too long they will all be mine! Beautifully remastered! I can't wait.
Even still, Archie Bunker's Place is not All in the Family and Mayberry RFD is not The Andy Griffith Show. They are reported separately for profit participation and such, and therefore are properly considered separate, independent projects. If they are tracked separately (for profit particpations and residuals) and syndicated separately, they are not the same series.