Wiseguy
Supporting Actor
- Joined
- Dec 31, 2011
- Messages
- 933
- Real Name
- Erich P. Wise
Barney Miller - Complete Series.
This is another which I'd not intended to collect the entire series, planning to stop with S5. I already own copies of S1-S4 and have just been waiting for a "deal" ($10 or less for a new copy) for S5. Amazon then goes and puts the Complete Series on sale at a price that meant the last 4 seasons (Fish S1 is not included in this set - that's OK as I recall not caring for it much) would be ~$12/each (ignoring S1-S4 - add those and it's a bit over $6/each season). For that price, and that S4 is constantly in the $17 range, I couldn't let the deal pass.
As a regular viewer of Barney Miller on ABC, I had always thought seasons 6 and 7 were an improvement over seasons 4 and 5, even with the absence of Jack Soo. The loss of Abe Vigoda in the fourth season, Jack Soo (near the end, with another blah temporary replacement) and also the audience itself halfway through the season was too much of a letdown from the excellent third season. The direction was a bit lazy in the 4th season. In one episode we see Hal Linden just standing in the back waiting for his cue, then moves into the next scene as if he had just passed by naturally. And the unforgivable scene in Eviction Part 1 where Inspector Luger is informing Barney of a very serious piece of news and actor Ron Carey is seen smiling at the news! Why the scene wasn't redone is not known. Then we lose Jack Soo again in the fifth season.
Then the final season took a dip in quality again partially due to the loss of regular director Noam Pitlik. Even Danny Arnold's directing seemed sluggish. Perhaps the worst episode of the entire series was the guy who thought he was possessed (the same guy who thought he was a werewolf in the third season). Unfortunately someone made the decision to amplify his voice to make his possession seem real. The B plot? A large woman who couldn't fit into her jeans. On the other hand they increased the continuing subplots from episode to episode. What is considered ordinary in today's sitcoms Barney Miller perhaps pioneered as far back as 1977 when Harris was looking for an apartment and it continued through most of the season. Later that season marital problems between Barney and his wife began to surface and that subplot was developed in the fifth season. So the fourth, fifth and eighth seasons weren't complete losses. I just thought the writing, directing and acting came together better in the sixth and seventh.