bujaki
Senior HTF Member
My wife and I liked this film. It's a tough one, but your penultimate paragraph explains it quite well.Disobedience (2017): After the death of her father, Ronit Krushka (Rachel Weisz) returns to the orthodox Jewish London community she abruptly left ten years earlier. Her father was a highly respected Rav, and she has had no contact with him, or anyone from her childhood since her departure. She has spent the last ten years working in New York as a photographer, using the name Ronnie Curtis.
It's probably best to go into a viewing of Disobedience not knowing many more details than that. Like a lot of movies, trailers, reviews and synopses reveal far too much. I didn't know any more than I've already said, so I'll just talk about generalities. I think this could have been a great movie, and it does have a lot of great moments. There are several related themes playing out, but I feel there was a desire to increase the movie's popularity by including scenes that are distractingly salacious. To me, they ground the flow of the movie to a halt and sold the greater concept short. The movie is rated 'R', but I was a little surprised it wasn't 'NC-17' due to that five minutes.
That one (to me, annoying) flaw doesn't erase the rest of the story, which is definitely powerful. It deals with the paradox of Faith, Orthodoxy, Grace, and Free Will, and takes them on head first. In fact, I'd say that the final 25 minutes are as good as drama gets. A wonderful example where everyone sacrifices and nobody gets what they (think they) want, but they all ultimately follow the guidance of their mutual love for each other.
Alessandro Nivola is the real surprise here. He is outstanding.
BTW, it's free on Prime.