lark144
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Feb 22, 2012
- Messages
- 2,108
- Real Name
- mark gross
Anyone who wrote (& I'm somewhat paraphrasing from memory) "There is more artistry in a single shot of Brain de Palma's "The Fury" than in Alfred Hitchcock's entire body of work" is not a critic I can really agree with or admire, as there seem to be missing a basic understanding of what cinema is all about. Pauline Kael would overpraise directors and screenwriters she liked (such as de Palma and Herman Mankiewicz) in order to use them as battering rams to try and wreck the reputations of directors she didn't (such as Hitchcock and Wells) which is not exactly what I would call "bluntly honest".I think you're giving Kael too much credit, but, I guess we just have a fundamental disagreement about her.