Joseph DeMartino
Senior HTF Member
"Practically no decoders"? Both Dolby Digital (originally marketed as "AC-3") and DTS had been home audio formats for sometime before DVD arrived, thanks to laser discs. And even people who couldn't take advantage of full-blown digital surround sound were still getting hiss-free, non-degrading cd-audio quality stereo or DPL sound from their movies - something vastly better than VHS.
So, again, anybody could enjoy some benefit from DVD from the day the format launched, without buying any new equipment beyond the player itself and some DVD movies. No one who doesn't own or buy an HDTV gets any benefit whatsoever from hi-def DVD. So the suggestion that the fact that SD DVD sold more players in 2 months than HD-DVD has sold in six still tells us what it told us several posts ago - nothing. Even if your 15% in 2005 is correct (and I don't believe that single study because it contradicts the 15 million worldwide figure for 2006 which I've found in multiple sources. I think the study you linked to is probably flawed and their estimate way too optimistic.) But even if the 15% number is real, that still doesn't approach the 90% of U.S. homes that were SD-DVD capable when that format launched.
No flames, just facts, history and logic. Oh, and first-hand knowledge of what the U.S. market was like in 1997 - when I bought my first DVD player about 6 months after the format launched.
Regards,
Joe