ScottRE
Senior HTF Member
We disagree on this one. "Killers of the Deep" is one of my favorite episodes of the second season. While it is the first color episode to be fashioned around pre-existing footage, it's a great suspenseful game of cat and mouse as Nelson becomes a submarine hunter and Crane is stuck on the enemy submarine. Crane does his best to stymie the enemy even though he knows detection would likely mean his death.–––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––
NEXT ON VOYAGE TO THE BOTTOM OF THE SEA
“Killers of the Deep”
This warmonger-oriented adventure suffers from strong anachronism because it’s written like a traditional WWII Navy narrative that stretches endlessly and the sets of the destroyer and the sub are terribly vintage but, at least, it’s a return to the season 1 Navy realism. A submarine from a small Central America nation hijacks the American missiles from their underwater silos. Oddly enough, Nelson is first only obsessed by the missing missiles and not by Crane. The action is divided in two: owing to the sudden death of the high officers, Nelson directs the US destroyer and Crane is held prisoner in the enemy sub and does his best to be spotted by the sonar: he makes two attempts (the klaxon in the control room and the noise in the air duct) during silent running.
As in “The Machines Strike Back”, one Seaview lead is locked up in the supply room and, here, Crane manages to remove his handcuffs with a wire. As in “Terror on the Dinosaur Island”, the prologue ends with two Seaview officers force to leave by parachute the flying sub but unlike the previous one, an enemy submarine fires a missile at them. Nelson is fished up by a US destroyer unlike Crane by the crew of bald-headed Captain Tomaz Ruiz (actor Michael Ansara) and his second-in-command Manolo (actor James Frawley). After undergoing two salvos, Nelson disarms a live torpedo which penetrates the hull during four minutes, helped by a sailor. Later, after a fatal torpedo, Nelson orders the crew to abandon the ship but he heads to the sub to ram it. In the control room, Crane guns down Manolo and struggles against Ruiz when water leaks occur. Nelson throws out a rope to Crane standing in the deck of the sub to join him in the ship: that scene is really not realistic at all.
The film editor supervised by the script editor use footages from the 20th Century Fox WWII Navy feature film The Enemy Below (co-starring David Hedison) to support that drama and it’s quite inappropriate when we witness German sailors inside the sub. The interior set of the enemy sub is extremely tiny and cheap. We don’t know the enemy nation because the sub has no emblem but the main drive of Captain Tomaz Ruiz may give you an idea: “a very small country with a few nuclear missiles… suddenly becomes a very large country.” Is it Cuba? Who knows? During the epilogue, Nelson quickly points out an island on the table map of the control room.
As in many scripts by Woodfield and Balter, find two recurring elements: disarming a bomb and crawling into the vent. The guest cast for the US Navy is insignificant even though the son of John Wayne is part of it. Both actors Michael Ansara (“Hotline”) and James Frawley (“The Exile”) return from season 1.
This is the first episode in production order where a flying submarine is lost. The teaser is extremely tense and exciting as the FS1 is shot down. Crane is able to bail out, but Nelson is trapped aboard and guides it down well enough to survive the crash but not enough to save the ship. There is no music when the sub hits the water which goes a long way in selling the devastation since they use the same diving footage as usual to illustrate the crash. The act two climax also has no music and these stylistic choices were uncommon for Irwin Allen.
Some fans asked why Nelson and crane put life preservers on when their leather jackets serve that purpose (as stated in "Leviathan"). I figured it was because they had to have the parachutes.
It's interesting you bring up "The Machines Strike Back" and the similarities. While that episode is light and over the top, this one feels darker and more serious. Even, dare I say it, more realistic.
Basehart is excellent as he pushes Crane's fate out of his mind while he concentrates on finding the absconded missiles and the sub which has them. Hedison is equally good as the put upon Crane kneecapping the sub crew at every turn.
The enemy sub set is the same one used in "...And Five of Us Are Left." It's a dingy and grimy set and the most realistic subset in the series. The crew of that sub is sweaty and filthy. Michael Ansara is magnetic as Ruiz with his shaved head beaded with sweat throughout. Ansara was legitimately bald here, his head shaved for a stage run in The King and I. When he appeared on Lost in Space a while later that year, he was wearing a skull cap. While Irwin Allen liked him bald, mostly likely the play was over and Ansara was growing his hair back. He appeared bald in the "Secret Weapon" episode of The Time Tunnel. If he was wearing a skull cap there, it was more realistic than on Lost in Space.
Obviously, the footage was taken from The Enemy Below. What's amusing is that the plot made it impossible to use David Hedison's footage from the film since he was on the sub.
There are a great many fine moments in this episode. Nelson mentally figuring out how long Ruiz would take before firing the second round, the disarming of the unexploded torpedo, the dolly zoom of Nelson as he rams the sub and the really competent way the U.S.S. Macklin crew responds. Yes, this footage means they are using WWII ships and equipment when the series was based in the 70's at this point. Now that we're so far past when this series aired, it probably doesn't seem as out of place as then since a) battleships don't change all THAT much and b) Ruiz would have had a surplus sub and it is stated that they were in old submarine. I also appreciated how the crew of the sub is made up of new faces to the series and not the usual background guys from the Seaview repurposed.
This is the first episode to use Leigh Harline's music from The Last Wagon in the battle scenes and this music would be used a lot in the series going forward. "Dead Men's Doubloons" kicks off the episode with it. In fact, a lot of music from The Enemy Below is used in this episode and the series itself.
I didn't find Crane's escape by rope all that unconvincing and the utter relief and joy on Nelson's face when they finally meet up is really great. Unlike the infighting on Lost in Space, he the two leads on Voyage really hit it off and were genuine friends.
I love this one a lot and revisit it often. Really well done seafaring combat episode.
Last edited: