mark-edk
Second Unit
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2002
- Messages
- 465
I don't think a 5th season episode is a good way to dip into 'That Girl'. It's a season Marlo Thomas didn't want to do, with a change in the storyline (the proposal and impending wedding) that she didn't want to do either. The theme somehow sprouted lyrics and no longer synced with the visuals. However...
I'm a tough customer when it comes to comedies. I liked MTM but but rarely chuckled when watching it, leg alone laugh. Very few sitcoms will actually get a laugh out of me; exceptional sitcoms will elicit chuckles however. That Girl is one of the few that does. It's go-to viewing when I need cheering up. Even the presentation of show's title card is clever and makes me smile. I don't hold it against the show that the leads weren't fornicating. Half a century later and I'll wager there are few 'family shows' with unmarried leads going at it on network tv today. I haven't watched enough current sitcoms to know...maybe there are some, but then, would they really be 'family shows'? Just the other day I watched That Girl's season two premiere with Ethel Merman. A bright, funny show, with the great Lew Parker stealing scenes as Marlo's Dad. Very few episodes let me down, although the last season is not at the same level IMHO.
Humor is subjective. My cousin thought 'Clifford' was a hilarious off-beat movie. I thought it was mind-boggling and unfunny. Everyone reacts differently to comedy and that's why there's all sort of shows for all sorts of people. That Girl is one of those shows for me.
PS: Also high on my very short list of sitcoms are Gidget, Bosom Buddies, Danny Thomas, Abbott and Costello (season 1), and in first place, Mr and Mrs Ozzie Nelson. Probably a few more that slipped my mind but that would be about it,
I'm a tough customer when it comes to comedies. I liked MTM but but rarely chuckled when watching it, leg alone laugh. Very few sitcoms will actually get a laugh out of me; exceptional sitcoms will elicit chuckles however. That Girl is one of the few that does. It's go-to viewing when I need cheering up. Even the presentation of show's title card is clever and makes me smile. I don't hold it against the show that the leads weren't fornicating. Half a century later and I'll wager there are few 'family shows' with unmarried leads going at it on network tv today. I haven't watched enough current sitcoms to know...maybe there are some, but then, would they really be 'family shows'? Just the other day I watched That Girl's season two premiere with Ethel Merman. A bright, funny show, with the great Lew Parker stealing scenes as Marlo's Dad. Very few episodes let me down, although the last season is not at the same level IMHO.
Humor is subjective. My cousin thought 'Clifford' was a hilarious off-beat movie. I thought it was mind-boggling and unfunny. Everyone reacts differently to comedy and that's why there's all sort of shows for all sorts of people. That Girl is one of those shows for me.
PS: Also high on my very short list of sitcoms are Gidget, Bosom Buddies, Danny Thomas, Abbott and Costello (season 1), and in first place, Mr and Mrs Ozzie Nelson. Probably a few more that slipped my mind but that would be about it,