EDIT: This is our first step to having HD in our house. So I'm new on actually having HD. Well, not me. My dad is getting it. He wanted a new tv for his bedroom and wanted something with a small footprint. He almost got sold on some Sanyo EDTV Plasma (yeck!). So I did some research and I found a nice 42" DLP from Samsung. It is also about $600 cheaper and real HD. So the perdicament is this... Right now we only get digital SDTV Comcast cable. We also have two TiVos in the house. One in my Dads room and one in the kitchen. He wants to keep the ability to DVR and I am pretty sure he would like to do it in HD. So that means that he can't use his (older non-HD) Tivo in his room. Now I know that he could get an HD-DVR from Comcast. That would seem to be the solution. But! The DLP tv he is getting also supports CableCARD. If he gets the cablecard he wont have to fumble remotes and it would very clean. Unfortunatly, I don't believe that you can do any DVRing with it. So basically, should my Dad opt for the cleaner CableCARD? Or should he just get a new HD box with DVR?