What's new

Warner DVD's not working thread - watch to make sure they still play (1 Viewer)

CraigF

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2002
Messages
3,117
Location
Toronto area, Canada
Real Name
Craig
Can I take it that I'm quite likely to have problems with the Film Noir Classic Collection Vol. 4? I see some titles in this set mentioned a few times in the thread. Not sure if testing all the discs will do much, besides annoy me, since it's probably hard to get replacements here anyway. Best to know though. I do have one DVDP (Oppo) that is extremely tolerant of iffy discs, it's not gonna last that much longer either, kinda thought the discs would outlive it though... [Edit: the only disc that looks suspicious is the Crime Wave/Decoy one. These don't look like Cinram discs, based on what I'm used to Cinram discs looking like. But IDK. More: all play without a hiccup. Need to revisit a few titles.]

When this thread started up, I looked at the hundreds of WB titles in box sets on my shelf dedicated to them...and dreaded the thought of having to test-play each. I did look at (not play) a random sampling of the discs and they all looked "perfect", much nicer-looking than most more-recent DVDs I've bought. These WB DVDs were all purchased before BDs existed, so I think before the problem period, except IIRC the set mentioned above.
 
Last edited:

Arthur Powell

Second Unit
Joined
Feb 15, 2018
Messages
455
Real Name
Arthur
I'm fortunate with my TCM Laurel and Hardy Collection, in that only the semi damaged hub on the casing has become an issue. I did successfully play both Laurel and Hardy Features not very long ago, along with the TCM Original Hollywood Shorts Story DVD.

One of these days, I'll need to check my WHITE HEAT (1949) disc, along with some other mid to late '00 Warner DVD releases.

It just occurred to me that the city to where we've recently moved tends a bit towards higher humidity than at our previous address. As such, I'll need to be more mindful of this potential playback issue caused by disc rot moving forward.

CHEERS! :)

If your new residence is air conditioned, you may not need to be too concerned. Where I was living before had high humidity and no air conditioning (never really needed it because my prior residence was naturally cool). I'm now in a very low humidity climate so my discs may be breathing a sigh of relief. ;) Luckily I have a second copy of the TCM Archives Laurel and Hardy set that was given to me as a gift, and that copy looks great and plays perfectly. I'm still returning the copy I actually paid for if just for the sake of principle (which would be the reason why I would return my rotted DVD copy of The Jazz Singer even though I have already upgraded to the blu-ray).
 

Arthur Powell

Second Unit
Joined
Feb 15, 2018
Messages
455
Real Name
Arthur
Well, another Warners release just found itself the newest member of the "send to Sherri" club, and this one actually surprised me - The TCM Archives Garbo Silents Collection. It was released in 2005 (about a year prior to the start of the era of problem discs), but I did purchase it at Costco around 2007 so it's possible it may be from a later pressing. The first disc looks fine, and side 1 of disc 2 looks equally fine. However, side 2 had an odd look to it (the movie on that side of the disc is The Temptress). Instead of being smooth-looking and reflective, it looked dull and grainy. Sensing that something may be awry, I put it into one of my players for a spot check (advancing through the chapters and letting each one play for about thirty seconds). As expected, the movie wouldn't advance pass chapter 13 (how ironic) or a little bit past the move's half-way mark. One final remark - why couldn't they have just kept making these discs the same blasted way as they did in the late 90s and early 2000s! I have Warner discs from 1997 and 1998 (like Mister Roberts) that play perfectly after two decades! Grrrr.....
 
Last edited:

Tony Bensley

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2013
Messages
6,301
Location
Somewhere in Canada
Real Name
Anthony
If your new residence is air conditioned, you may not need to be too concerned. Where I was living before had high humidity and no air conditioning (never really needed it because my prior residence was naturally cool). I'm now in a very low humidity climate so my discs may be breathing a sigh of relief. ;) Luckily I have a second copy of the TCM Archives Laurel and Hardy set that was given to me as a gift, and that copy looks great and plays perfectly. I'm still returning the copy I actually paid for if just for the sake of principle (which would be the reason why I would return my rotted DVD copy of The Jazz Singer even though I have already upgraded to the blu-ray).
We do have AC in the main living room, so hopefully that'll be good enough for the video collection. However, due to space constraints, I'm keeping the bulk of my CDs in the bedroom (In a transparent plastic container!), where the air conditioning is less direct.

CHEERS! :)
 

Aunt Peg

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Dec 27, 2011
Messages
193
Real Name
William Edwards
I just watched Waterloo Bridge (1940) and it played fine.

Since discovered some of my discs going off I've been making an effort to watch a Warners film every Sunday night, though I'm going on holidays soon for 6 weeks to that will stop that for a while.

Just a quick question: Should I also be checking the really old Warner discs in snapper cases? I have done a spot check on some of them and none of them seem to have problems.
 

CraigF

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2002
Messages
3,117
Location
Toronto area, Canada
Real Name
Craig
We do have AC in the main living room, so hopefully that'll be good enough for the video collection. However, due to space constraints, I'm keeping the bulk of my CDs in the bedroom (In a transparent plastic container!), where the air conditioning is less direct.

CHEERS! :)
It might not be a bad idea to consider ripping your most favorite or difficult to replace DVDs while you can. The disc to look at, the rip to play. I say that to you, but I'll never do it myself! I did rip all my CDs though, quite a process, but mostly the tagging which the DVDs won't need.

I have similar humidity to you, near the Lake etc., and I haven't noticed any of the CD/DVD/BD rot probs that I've seen mentioned in the forums over the years. Knock on polycarbonate plastic... I store my round playing-objects in a room that has very light heating and A/C. It has a (locking) door partly so guests/house-sitters don't get any ideas, but mostly to keep some control over the environment. I have to suspect that moderation is partly the key, humid/dry and hot/cold cycles are probably worse than keeping it one way or the other, though dry and cool would seem good (I have no actual proof, just in my mind).
 

Arthur Powell

Second Unit
Joined
Feb 15, 2018
Messages
455
Real Name
Arthur
I just watched Waterloo Bridge (1940) and it played fine.

Since discovered some of my discs going off I've been making an effort to watch a Warners film every Sunday night, though I'm going on holidays soon for 6 weeks to that will stop that for a while.

Just a quick question: Should I also be checking the really old Warner discs in snapper cases? I have done a spot check on some of them and none of them seem to have problems.

Concerning the snapper cases, I would check them if you acquired them in or after 2006. The reason being is that while they may be in the pre-2004 packaging, the discs themselves may be repressings from the defective years. I picked up snapper copies of Arsenic and Old Lace, Splendor in the Grass and the Error Flynn The Prince and the Pauper from Costco around 2007. Figuring they were old stock, I didn't bother to check them until recently, and they had rotted. So, I guess that Warner made an excess amount of the snapper case artwork before 2004 and would use them for the repressings (at least that's the way I've rationalized it). If you acquired the snapper discs before 2006, you're probably safe.
 

Darby67

Screenwriter
Joined
Dec 4, 2009
Messages
1,490
Real Name
Sean
I finished watching Film Noir Classic Collection Volume 5 (the pressed disc version released on July 10, 2010 not the burned disc version released on May 23, 2017) and can happily report the all 4 of the following discs (2 films per disc) played perfectly:

Cornered/Desperate
The Phenix City Story/Dial 1119
Armored Car Robbery/Crime in the Streets
Deadline at Dawn/Backfire
 

Darby67

Screenwriter
Joined
Dec 4, 2009
Messages
1,490
Real Name
Sean
I finished watching Film Noir Classic Collection Volume 3 and can happily report the all 6 of the following discs played perfectly:

Border Incident
His Kind of Woman
Lady in the Lake
On Dangerous Ground
The Racket
Film Noir: Bringing Darkness to Light (documentary)
 
Last edited:

DFurr

Supporting Actor
Joined
Sep 6, 2010
Messages
832
Location
SoCal
Real Name
Don
I thought this was interesting. I copies this from the internet.


How long will a Blu Ray disc last?
Conclusion
Media Estimated Lifespan
CDs and DVDs 5-10 unrecorded, 2-5 recorded
Blu-Ray Not certain, probably over 2-5 recorded
M-Disc 1,000 years (theoretically)
Hard disk 3-5 years

Does anyone agree with those stats?
 

CraigF

Senior HTF Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2002
Messages
3,117
Location
Toronto area, Canada
Real Name
Craig
^ No. Strictly from anecdotal/empirical evidence. Mine and others. My oldest hard disk is ~35 years old and still works. My oldest DVDs are ~20 years old and still work. My oldest CDs are ~30 years old and still work. Etc. I doubt I'm an outlier, except for the HDD (which is the first Winchester consumer model).

I'm sure if you used archival storage methods most of those media could last an extremely long time. The issue would be devices to play them back, keeping those working. Probably.
 

Darby67

Screenwriter
Joined
Dec 4, 2009
Messages
1,490
Real Name
Sean
I finished watching Film Noir Classic Collection Volume 2 and can happily report the all 5 of the following discs played perfectly:

Born to Kill
Clash by Night
Crossfire
Dillinger
The Narrow Margin
 

Aunt Peg

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Dec 27, 2011
Messages
193
Real Name
William Edwards
I thought this was interesting. I copies this from the internet.


How long will a Blu Ray disc last?
Conclusion
Media Estimated Lifespan
CDs and DVDs 5-10 unrecorded, 2-5 recorded
Blu-Ray Not certain, probably over 2-5 recorded
M-Disc 1,000 years (theoretically)
Hard disk 3-5 years

Does anyone agree with those stats?

That does not sound right. If that was the case everyones older CDs & DVDs would have all completely failed by now and physical media would basically die because nobody would purchase something with such a short lifespan unless they watched a particular film on a regular basis.
 

Aunt Peg

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Dec 27, 2011
Messages
193
Real Name
William Edwards
Just finished watching Pride and Prejudice (1940) and it played fine. Also of note was that the print it in good condition but would need some restoration for Blu Ray.
 

Matt Hough

Reviewer
Senior HTF Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2006
Messages
22,727
Location
Charlotte, NC
Real Name
Matt Hough
Just finished watching Pride and Prejudice (1940) and it played fine. Also of note was that the print it in good condition but would need some restoration for Blu Ray.
Yes, I thought the same thing about it the last time I watched it. It would need some work for Blu-ray.
 

Darby67

Screenwriter
Joined
Dec 4, 2009
Messages
1,490
Real Name
Sean
I finished watching Film Noir Classic Collection Volume 1 and can happily report the all 5 of the following discs played perfectly:

The Asphalt Jungle
Gun Crazy
Murder, My Sweet
Out of the Past
The Set-Up
 

Aunt Peg

Stunt Coordinator
Joined
Dec 27, 2011
Messages
193
Real Name
William Edwards
Just watching Fury (1936) and it played fine.

I'm afraid it's another film that will need a little work for a Blu Ray release.
 

Darby67

Screenwriter
Joined
Dec 4, 2009
Messages
1,490
Real Name
Sean
I was able to buy pressed disc replacements of Black Legion and Lady Killer (from Warner Gangsters Collection Volume 3), and Act of Violence/Mystery Street (from Warner Film Noir Collection Volume 4) on Amazon, Ebay, etc.

I watched the pressed disc replacements of Black Legion and Lady Killer this evening and both played perfectly.

I will watch Act of Violence/Mystery Street tomorrow night and will provide an update then.
 

Darby67

Screenwriter
Joined
Dec 4, 2009
Messages
1,490
Real Name
Sean
Unfortunately, the replacement pressed disc of Act of Violence/Mystery Street that ordered from Amazon pixelated and froze at the opening WB logo :angry: It's on its way back for a full refund.

I purchased a new pressed disc version from a different seller on Amazon and will update once it arrives.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Forum Sponsors

Latest Articles

Forum statistics

Threads
346,071
Messages
4,766,053
Members
141,662
Latest member
NAVS
Top