Robert Saccone
Premium
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2000
- Messages
- 924
Lots of people feel that way. a straight port of the novel to the screen wouldn't have made a lasting treasure that the move has turned out to be.I have to say without hesitation that the movie is much superior to the novel.
I tend to keep them in separate mental compartments and appreciate each them for what they are. I love that it is based on Long Island where I've lived since leaving the city at 12. For whatever reason my yearly ritual is to read it on the beach when we take our vacation out on Fire Island.
The novel holds a fond memory for me as it is the first adult novel that I read as a 9 year old. The first copy my mom got me my stepfather decided it wasn't appropriate and he made his own edits by blacking out sections and wrote in his own text to bridge his edits. Needless to say I never looked at that copy again. My mother bought me a new copy and told him not to touch it because she felt it was more important to encourage me to read.
I saw the new documentary tonight. Tino's right, it is terrific. I love that Greg Nicotero saved the last Bruce from the original mold. I can't wait to go see it as the museum this fall.