Andy Young
Stunt Coordinator
- Joined
- Nov 30, 1999
- Messages
- 78
This is not an advertisement! I am asking for purchasing advice. It suddenly became clear to me that my thread title might appear to be offering a deal (sales) to prospective buyers. There is no way for me to edit the thread title, though. Sorry.
This is a follow-up message to this thread: Paradigm vs B&W for HT.
Local shop has Performance bookshelf speakers: Micro, Atom, Titan.
Also has Monitor bookshelfs: MiniMonitor, Monitor 5
Also has Monitor floorstanding: Monitor 7 and Monitor 11
No Performance floorstanding, no CC-270 center speaker (only 170 & 370), and no PDR-12 (only 10).
I auditioned the following systems (using my material: Toy Story 2 and The Good, The Bad, & The Ugly (great for demoing center channels -- the whole movie is dolby digital mono):
I also don't want to pay for Monitor series speakers. I'm just not that discriminating of a listener. Couldn't hear any significant difference between Titan and Micro Monitor, e.g.
QUESTIONS
Thanks for all of your help so far. I've always been impressed with the level of support here, whether the person is asking about a $500 home-theater-in-a-box or about $20,000 Nautilus speakers.
I look forward to reading your suggestions.
Andy
This is a follow-up message to this thread: Paradigm vs B&W for HT.
Local shop has Performance bookshelf speakers: Micro, Atom, Titan.
Also has Monitor bookshelfs: MiniMonitor, Monitor 5
Also has Monitor floorstanding: Monitor 7 and Monitor 11
No Performance floorstanding, no CC-270 center speaker (only 170 & 370), and no PDR-12 (only 10).
I auditioned the following systems (using my material: Toy Story 2 and The Good, The Bad, & The Ugly (great for demoing center channels -- the whole movie is dolby digital mono):
- Titan mains, Atom surrounds, CC-170 center, PSB-10 sub.
- Monitor 7 mains, Atom surrounds, CC-170 center, PSB-10 sub.
I also don't want to pay for Monitor series speakers. I'm just not that discriminating of a listener. Couldn't hear any significant difference between Titan and Micro Monitor, e.g.
QUESTIONS
- Would it be prudent to buy the Phantom floorstanding speaker as my main without auditioning? Keep in mind that I've listened to its little brother the Titan (which I liked) and its cousin the Monitor 7 (which I like more than the Titan, but not $420 more). Am I safe, at this point, ordering the Phantom without listening to that exact speaker?
- The Monitor 7 is $150 more than Phantom. Should I go with the Monitor 7, mated with CC-270 (not timbre matched), and Atoms? I'm already over budget, so I'd prefer not to spend the extra $150.
- I have not listened to the CC-270, only the CC-170. The 170 was OK, but didn't wow me at all. For an extra $60, I can move up to the 270. Is it worth it? The 370 is yet another $80 ($300) and out of my price range. Thoughts on my center channel choice?
- The PDR-10 sounded great to me. Very low and hard. Remember, I don't have much experience with subs, so don't laugh at me. ;-) My room is a bit bigger and open, so I figured it was worth the $60 to move to the PDR-12. Thoughts?
Thanks for all of your help so far. I've always been impressed with the level of support here, whether the person is asking about a $500 home-theater-in-a-box or about $20,000 Nautilus speakers.
I look forward to reading your suggestions.
Andy