Ted Lee
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- May 8, 2001
- Messages
- 8,390
as with all best-of type compilations, assuming you already have all the albums and unless they have something different to offer, what's the point right? so, as with their previous best-of compilation (1980-1990), u2 decided to make this a 2-cd set. so, for someone like me who already has all their stuff, i was really hoping for something to stand-out on the second cd.
the best of
all their main hits from the last decade are on the first cd. some of the songs have been redone (titled "new mix") but they essentially sound the same. they included a couple of nice choices including a personal favorite "miss sarajevo" (available on the passengers cd they did a while ago) and the william orbit mix of "electrical storm". a couple of rarer tracks are also included which help to vary-up the compilation. overall a decent set-list.
the b-sides
this cd is much more hit or miss. it consists of alternate selections you may not have heard before, plus some of their popular hits "remixed". the alternate selections are nice...i hadn't heard them before so it was a pleasant surprise. they even include a cover of the beatles "happiness is a warm gun".
the remixes are okay. (i usually don't like remixes because their often done so "aggressively" that the remix loses the essence of the original track.) some of the remixes were pretty awesome including "lady with the spinning head" and "salome".
but...
"even better than the real thing" got a techno-dance beat that almost worked, "numb" tried to get funky but failed, "if god will send his angels" was NOT a song that should have been remixed and "lemon" was just awful. i get the feeling that these mixes were thrown on the second cd just to justify the second cd's own existence!
bonus dvd
i guess for a short time, they're also including this bonus dvd (packaged in a separate cardboard sleeve) which has 4 videos on it. there is a live performance of "please" (?), a video for "beautiful day", a promo for (i think) an upcoming videos compilation, and lastly, some sort of video-remix-thing-a-ma-jig. cool enough for free.
overall, not a bad compilation if you don't already have their catalog, or if you're a completists like me. otherwise, try to audition it first.
i give this cd a "B-"
CD Details
the best of
all their main hits from the last decade are on the first cd. some of the songs have been redone (titled "new mix") but they essentially sound the same. they included a couple of nice choices including a personal favorite "miss sarajevo" (available on the passengers cd they did a while ago) and the william orbit mix of "electrical storm". a couple of rarer tracks are also included which help to vary-up the compilation. overall a decent set-list.
the b-sides
this cd is much more hit or miss. it consists of alternate selections you may not have heard before, plus some of their popular hits "remixed". the alternate selections are nice...i hadn't heard them before so it was a pleasant surprise. they even include a cover of the beatles "happiness is a warm gun".
the remixes are okay. (i usually don't like remixes because their often done so "aggressively" that the remix loses the essence of the original track.) some of the remixes were pretty awesome including "lady with the spinning head" and "salome".
but...
"even better than the real thing" got a techno-dance beat that almost worked, "numb" tried to get funky but failed, "if god will send his angels" was NOT a song that should have been remixed and "lemon" was just awful. i get the feeling that these mixes were thrown on the second cd just to justify the second cd's own existence!
bonus dvd
i guess for a short time, they're also including this bonus dvd (packaged in a separate cardboard sleeve) which has 4 videos on it. there is a live performance of "please" (?), a video for "beautiful day", a promo for (i think) an upcoming videos compilation, and lastly, some sort of video-remix-thing-a-ma-jig. cool enough for free.
overall, not a bad compilation if you don't already have their catalog, or if you're a completists like me. otherwise, try to audition it first.
i give this cd a "B-"
CD Details