Pete York
Supporting Actor
- Joined
- Dec 1, 2004
- Messages
- 610
The Bachelor and the Bobby-Soxer (1947) Dir: Irving Reis
Silly lark of a film that never rises above the material, despite the excellent cast. Cary Grant plays the titular bachelor, a playboy-type who through a wacky misunderstanding will maybe, just maybe, learn what real love is. Yes, even by this time this was a role Grant could’ve sleepwalked through, but he remains his ever charming, likeable self. Is he simply playing ‘Cary Grant’, the screen persona often co-credited to Leo McCarey? Probably, but then it would only be natural to take a different tact on say, a Hitchcock film, as opposed to extremely light fare like this or Mr. Blandings.
The adorable Shirley Temple is the bobby-soxer, the oh-so-mature-for-her-age 17-year-old Susan Turner, whose sneaking into the apartment of Grant’s Richard Nugent (he’s an artist, she wants to model for him), where she’s caught, begins the sequence of his unfortunate events. Faced with jail time, Nugent is asked by Judge Margaret Turner (Myrna Loy), who just happens to be the girl’s older sister, to instead date Susan until her crush on him ends. If you think that sometime during this process Loy and Grant fall in love, well, I don’t want to give it away but you just may be on the right track.
It’s not a great role for Loy, she rarely has any comedic moments, and the plausibility of her being Shirley Temple’s older sister is so stretched that even Robert ‘See No Evil’ Osborne commented on it after this particular showing on TCM. Rudy Vallee plays her square, would-be but no-hope beau. Ray Collins and Harry Davenport also add their familiar excellent support.
While I like plenty of films based on goofy premises, the difference here is that The Bachelor and the Bobby-Soxer is never more than mildly amusing, despite its pedigree as an Oscar®-winner for best screenplay. The best bit is Grant acting like a ‘hip’ teenager in order to make a bad impression on Susan’s staid family (and have them call the dating off, I suppose). The other big comic scenes (the picnic, the dinner at the club) were either mediocre slapstick or had no laughs.
Hardly essential, but fine for fans of Grant.
:star: :star: out of 4
Silly lark of a film that never rises above the material, despite the excellent cast. Cary Grant plays the titular bachelor, a playboy-type who through a wacky misunderstanding will maybe, just maybe, learn what real love is. Yes, even by this time this was a role Grant could’ve sleepwalked through, but he remains his ever charming, likeable self. Is he simply playing ‘Cary Grant’, the screen persona often co-credited to Leo McCarey? Probably, but then it would only be natural to take a different tact on say, a Hitchcock film, as opposed to extremely light fare like this or Mr. Blandings.
The adorable Shirley Temple is the bobby-soxer, the oh-so-mature-for-her-age 17-year-old Susan Turner, whose sneaking into the apartment of Grant’s Richard Nugent (he’s an artist, she wants to model for him), where she’s caught, begins the sequence of his unfortunate events. Faced with jail time, Nugent is asked by Judge Margaret Turner (Myrna Loy), who just happens to be the girl’s older sister, to instead date Susan until her crush on him ends. If you think that sometime during this process Loy and Grant fall in love, well, I don’t want to give it away but you just may be on the right track.
It’s not a great role for Loy, she rarely has any comedic moments, and the plausibility of her being Shirley Temple’s older sister is so stretched that even Robert ‘See No Evil’ Osborne commented on it after this particular showing on TCM. Rudy Vallee plays her square, would-be but no-hope beau. Ray Collins and Harry Davenport also add their familiar excellent support.
While I like plenty of films based on goofy premises, the difference here is that The Bachelor and the Bobby-Soxer is never more than mildly amusing, despite its pedigree as an Oscar®-winner for best screenplay. The best bit is Grant acting like a ‘hip’ teenager in order to make a bad impression on Susan’s staid family (and have them call the dating off, I suppose). The other big comic scenes (the picnic, the dinner at the club) were either mediocre slapstick or had no laughs.
Hardly essential, but fine for fans of Grant.
:star: :star: out of 4